Lesson 11 of 36
The more stable carbocation decides where each group adds
With an unsymmetrical alkene, the route through the more stable carbocation is faster, so it gives the major product.
A-Level 9476 (2026-2027)
I can describe alkene chemistry using ethene and analogous structures.Syllabus
Syllabus 9476, 11.4(b). Describe alkene chemistry using ethene and analogous structures.
I can apply and explain Markovnikov addition.Syllabus
Syllabus 9476, 11.4(c). Apply and explain Markovnikov addition.
The more stable carbocation decides where each group adds
With an unsymmetrical alkene, the route through the more stable carbocation is faster, so it gives the major product.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
Propene, CH3CH=CH2, reacts with hydrogen bromide. What is the major product?
Show the answer
2-bromopropane, via the secondary carbocation
H+ adds to the end carbon to make the more stable secondary carbocation, which Br- then attacks.
Hydrogen halides, HX, add in the same two steps. The π bond accepts H+ from the δ+ H of H-X, and the H-X bond pair moves onto X. This gives a carbocation and X-. Then X- donates a lone pair to the positive carbon. With propene, H can add to either end of the C=C bond, so two different carbocations are possible.
- Draw both choices for step 1
For CH3CH=CH2 + HBr, H can add to C1 to give CH3-C+H-CH3, or to C2 to give CH3CH2CH2+.
- Compare carbocation stability
Alkyl groups push electron density towards C+ and spread out its charge. So the more alkyl groups on C+, the more stable it is: tertiary > secondary > primary. Here the secondary carbocation has two alkyl groups and the primary has one, so the secondary one forms faster.
- Add the nucleophile to the more stable positive centre
The major product is CH3CHBrCH3. H has added to the carbon that already had more H atoms.
Markovnikov's rule says that H adds to the C=C carbon that already has more H atoms. It predicts the major product. The minor product still forms: a little 1-bromopropane comes from the primary carbocation. The same argument decides where groups go when the electrophile is δ+ Br from Br2, as the worked example shows. Radical addition, with peroxides present, follows a different mechanism and is outside this course.
The rule is named after Vladimir Markovnikov. It came out of his 1869 doctoral thesis at Kazan University in Russia, and he published it in 1870.
Worked exampleBromine water and bromine in sodium chloride solution
Propene is shaken with (a) Br2(aq), and (b) Br2 dissolved in concentrated NaCl(aq). Use the mechanism to predict the organic products and explain where each group ends up.
Try it first. Then show the worked stepsHide the worked steps
- Step 1 is the same in both mixtures, because Br2 is the only electrophile present. The π bond attacks the δ+ Br. If Br bonds to C1 (the CH2 end), the positive charge sits on C2: CH3-C+H-CH2Br, a secondary carbocation. If Br bonds to C2, the charge sits on C1: a primary carbocation.
- The secondary carbocation has two carbon groups bonded to C+; the primary has only one. Alkyl groups donate electrons and disperse the positive charge, so the secondary carbocation is more stable and forms faster. Br therefore ends up on C1 and the nucleophile on C2.
- In step 2, any nucleophile in the mixture can attack C+. In Br2(aq), water is present in far larger amounts than Br-. A water lone pair attacks C2, and the oxygen then loses H+. This gives CH3CH(OH)CH2Br, 1-bromopropan-2-ol. Some Br- also attacks, giving a little CH3CHBrCH2Br, 1,2-dibromopropane.
- In concentrated NaCl(aq), Cl- is present at high concentration, so it also competes for C+. This gives CH3CHClCH2Br, 1-bromo-2-chloropropane, alongside the products from water and Br-.
- NaCl supplies only Cl-, a nucleophile. There is no δ+ Cl electrophile to start step 1, so no product has Cl on C1 and 1,2-dichloropropane cannot form.
(a) Mainly 1-bromopropan-2-ol, CH3CH(OH)CH2Br, with a little 1,2-dibromopropane. (b) 1-Bromo-2-chloropropane, CH3CHClCH2Br, as well as those two products. In every product Br is on C1 and the nucleophile is on C2, because both mixtures go through the more stable secondary carbocation.
Check your understanding
Bromine in concentrated NaCl(aq) is shaken with 2-methylpropene, (CH3)2C=CH2. Which compound is not formed?
Show the answer
(CH3)2CBrCH2Cl
The only electrophile is delta+ Br from Br2. Br adds to the CH2 end to give the tertiary carbocation (CH3)2C+-CH2Br. A Cl on the CH2 carbon would need a Cl electrophile, and NaCl supplies only Cl-.
Watch out for this
A student says: "2-bromopropane is the major product because it is a more stable compound than 1-bromopropane." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
The major product comes from the faster route, through the more stable carbocation, CH3-CH+-CH3. The stability of the final products does not decide it. A June 2022 Cambridge report on HCl and 2-methylpropene gives 'more stable halogenoalkane compound' as a frequent wrong answer.