Lesson 14 of 36
SN1 forms a carbocation before the nucleophile attacks
Tertiary halogenoalkanes ionise to stable carbocations. The flat carbocation is attacked from either side, so a chiral start gives a racemic mixture.
A-Level 9476 (2026-2027)
I can explain both nucleophilic-substitution mechanisms.Syllabus
Syllabus 9476, 11.3(n). Explain both nucleophilic-substitution mechanisms.
I can explain substitution stereochemistry for optically active substrates.Syllabus
Syllabus 9476, 11.5(b). Explain substitution stereochemistry for optically active substrates.
SN1 forms a carbocation before the nucleophile attacks
Tertiary halogenoalkanes ionise to stable carbocations. The flat carbocation is attacked from either side, so a chiral start gives a racemic mixture.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
2-bromo-2-methylpropane and 1-bromobutane are each warmed with water. Which is hydrolysed faster?
Show the answer
2-bromo-2-methylpropane, via a stable tertiary carbocation
It is tertiary, so it ionises to a tertiary carbocation stabilised by three alkyl groups. That SN1 route is fast.
First step: heterolytic C-Br cleavage
The curly arrow starts at the carbon-bromine bond and ends at bromine. The carbon has three carbon groups and becomes a positively charged carbocation after losing bromide.
The nucleophile then gives a lone pair to the positive carbon. With OH-, this gives the alcohol directly. With H2O, it first gives a protonated alcohol, which then loses H+. The rate equation is rate = k[halogenoalkane], because the slow step, ionisation, happens before the nucleophile attacks.
Second step with water: make the new C-O bond
A lone pair on water oxygen points towards the positive carbon of the tert-butyl carbocation. Carbon has three methyl groups in a planar arrangement before attack. The resulting oxygen has three bonds and a positive charge in the protonated alcohol.
- Draw the protonated alcohol
Oxygen is bonded to carbon and two H atoms, so place the positive charge on O.
- Use another water molecule as a base
Draw an arrow from its oxygen lone pair to an H on the protonated alcohol. At the same time, draw an arrow from that O-H bond back to the alcohol oxygen.
- Check atoms and charge
(CH3)3C-OH2+ + H2O → (CH3)3COH + H3O+. Oxygen in the neutral alcohol now has two bonds; the overall charge remains +1.
As in Markovnikov addition, carbocations with more alkyl groups are more stable: tertiary > secondary > primary. So tertiary halogenoalkanes ionise easily. One that would give a primary carbocation is unlikely to react by SN1.
In 1935, Edward Hughes and Christopher Ingold studied these substitutions in halogenoalkanes and described two main mechanisms, SN1 and SN2. Ingold led the chemistry department at University College London.
The carbocation is flat (trigonal planar). If the starting compound is chiral, the nucleophile can attack from either face. In the simple model this gives equal amounts of both enantiomers, which is racemisation. In reality the leaving ion can partly block one face, so the mixture may not be exactly equal. The key contrast is with SN2, which gives inversion. The tert-butyl example shown is itself achiral, because its three methyl groups are identical.
Worked exampleUse a chiral starting material to predict the SN1 products
One enantiomer of 3-bromo-3-methylhexane is hydrolysed by SN1. What is the stereochemical result?
Try it first. Then show the worked stepsHide the worked steps
- Its C-Br carbon carries Br, CH3, C2H5 and CH2CH2CH3: four different groups. So it is both tertiary and chiral.
- C-Br breaks and Br- leaves. Redraw the carbocation carbon and its three groups as flat (trigonal planar). The original wedge arrangement is lost.
- A water lone pair can attack either face of this plane. After losing H+, each product carbon carries OH, methyl, ethyl and propyl groups.
- Draw one product in 3D and reflect it to get the other. The four groups differ, so the two cannot be superimposed.
Equal amounts of the two enantiomers of 3-methylhexan-3-ol form: a racemic mixture. The path through a flat carbocation explains why the starting optical activity is lost.
The two alcohols produced by opposite-face attack
Each product carbon has methyl and ethyl on ordinary bonds in the plane of the page. OH is on a solid wedge, towards the viewer, and n-propyl is on a hashed wedge, away. Reflecting every attached group exchanges left and right positions and gives non-superimposable mirror images.
| Feature | SN1 | SN2 |
|---|---|---|
| Elementary sequence | Slow ionisation, then fast attack. | Concerted bond formation and breaking. |
| Intermediate | Planar carbocation. | No carbocation; one transition state. |
| Rate law in the simple model | k[RX]. | k[RX][Nu]. |
| Main substrate factor | Carbocation stability. | Steric access to the carbon. |
| Chiral substrate outcome | Racemisation through two-face attack. | Inversion through backside attack. |
Check your understanding
Doubling [OH-] does not change the rate of hydrolysis of 2-bromo-2-methylpropane. Which explanation is correct?
Show the answer
OH- reacts only after the slow step, the ionisation of C-Br
The slow step sets the rate, and only the halogenoalkane takes part in it. So rate = k[(CH3)3CBr].