Skip to notes
9476 / 2027
Organic Chemistry

Lesson 12 of 36

Benzene swaps an H for an electrophile and keeps its ring

Benzene needs a catalyst to make a strong electrophile. The intermediate then loses H+, which restores the stable delocalised ring.

A-Level 9476 (2026-2027)

  • I can compare benzene and alkene reactivity through delocalisation.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9476, 11.3(e). Compare benzene and alkene reactivity through delocalisation.

  • I can describe aromatic electrophilic substitution.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9476, 11.3(m). Describe aromatic electrophilic substitution.

  • I can describe the specified aromatic-ring reactions.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9476, 11.4(d). Describe the specified aromatic-ring reactions.

Benzene swaps an H for an electrophile and keeps its ring

Benzene needs a catalyst to make a strong electrophile. The intermediate then loses H+, which restores the stable delocalised ring.

Make a guess. You are not marked.

Bromine is mixed with benzene in the dark at room temperature, with no catalyst. What happens?

  1. Bromobenzene forms quickly without any help
  2. The colour fades as bromine adds across the ring
  3. Nothing visible; the bromine colour stays
Show the answer

Nothing visible; the bromine colour stays

The delocalised ring is stable, and Br2 alone is not a strong enough electrophile. A catalyst such as FeBr3 is needed to make Br+.

Benzene has six π electrons delocalised around its ring. They are less available than the two π electrons of a C=C bond, and an attack breaks up the delocalised ring, which costs energy. So benzene does not react with Br2 alone, as an alkene does. It needs a stronger electrophile, made with a catalyst.

To add one bromine to benzene, use Br2 with anhydrous AlBr3. AlBr3 is a Lewis acid. It accepts electron density from Br2 and makes it strongly polar. You can write this as Br2 + AlBr3 ⇌ Br+ + AlBr4-. This equation shows where the electrons go. It does not mean free Br+ ions sit in the bottle.

The aromatic pi system attacks the activated bromine

A curly arrow starts at the aromatic pi system and points to electrophilic bromine. Forming a carbon-bromine sigma bond temporarily interrupts the cyclic delocalisation.

This step forms a positively charged intermediate. One ring carbon now carries both H and Br and is tetrahedral for a moment. So do not draw a full circle in this intermediate. Instead, draw a horseshoe (a partial ring) over the five carbons that still share the delocalised electrons, with the + inside it. Leave the CHBr carbon out.

The positive intermediate in this step is often called the Wheland intermediate, after the American chemist George Willard Wheland. Another name for it is a sigma complex.

Loss of H+ restores the aromatic pi system

One resonance form of the sigma complex has a ring carbon bearing H and Br, two remaining double bonds and a positive charge elsewhere. A base accepts H; the carbon-hydrogen bond pair moves into the adjacent ring bond, restoring the aromatic system.

The base is a bromide ligand in AlBr4-. Removing the proton forms HBr and regenerates AlBr3. The displayed positive-charge position is one resonance contributor, not a fixed isolated charge.

Overall, C6H6 + Br2 → C6H5Br + HBr. Substitution replaces an H and keeps the delocalised ring. Addition would destroy the ring and its extra stability, which is why benzene prefers substitution. The catalyst is made again, so it must not appear as used up in the overall equation.

Check your understanding

Cyclohexene decolourises bromine at room temperature. Benzene reacts only when AlBr3 is added, and forms C6H5Br, not C6H6Br2. Which idea explains both facts?

  1. Benzene's six pi electrons are delocalised, so it cannot polarise Br2 alone, and substitution keeps the stable ring.
  2. AlBr3 removes hydrogen atoms from benzene first, so that bromine can then bond to the free carbons.
  3. Benzene has fewer pi electrons than cyclohexene, so it attracts bromine molecules more weakly.
Show the answer

Benzene's six pi electrons are delocalised, so it cannot polarise Br2 alone, and substitution keeps the stable ring.

Spread-out pi density makes benzene a weaker electron donor than a localised C=C, so a Lewis acid is needed to make Br+. Losing H+ from the intermediate restores the delocalised ring, which is more stable than any addition product.

Check your understanding

In alkene bromination the carbocation gains Br-. In benzene bromination the intermediate loses H+ instead. Why?

  1. Br- is too large to approach the ring, so the intermediate has to lose H+ to become neutral.
  2. Losing H+ restores the delocalised ring of six pi electrons, which is especially stable.
  3. The AlBr3 catalyst holds on to every Br- ion, so no bromide is free to add to the ring.
Show the answer

Losing H+ restores the delocalised ring of six pi electrons, which is especially stable.

The C-H bond pair returns to the ring, so the pi electrons are delocalised over all six carbons again. Adding Br- would leave two separate C=C bonds and lose that stability, so substitution wins.

Watch out for this

A student says: "Draw the partial ring over all six carbons and put + on the CHBr carbon." What is wrong with this?

Show the answer

That carbon is sp3, so it is not part of the delocalised system. Draw the horseshoe over the other five carbons, with the + inside it. A November 2022 Cambridge report lists this as a common error. The partly delocalised ring should not include the sp3 carbon, and the charge should not be on it.