What this lesson teaches
I can judge how Southeast Asian governments held on to power and what this led to.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments in consolidating power in different contexts and over time
Make a guess
Thai military rulers drew legitimacy from royal support. Do you think the king always backed them?
- No, he opposed military rule from 1957 onwards.
- Yes, the king gave his backing to whoever held power.
- No, in 1973 and 1992 he helped end army rule.
Show the answer
No, in 1973 and 1992 he helped end army rule.
In 1973 he backed the students and the military leaders left. In 1992 his intervention ended the crisis.
Monarchy and religion could give governments deep legitimacy, but they could also be used against rulers.
In Thailand, Sarit revived the prestige of the monarchy after 1957. King Bhumibol became the most respected man in the country. Army rulers drew legitimacy from royal support.
The Thai king could also restrain rulers. In October 1973 he stepped in, and the army leaders left the country.
In Malaysia, the Malay rulers and Islam were part of the constitution. In the 1980s Mahathir's government built up Islamic bodies to compete with PAS, the Islamic party.
Indonesia's rulers kept religion under control. By 1985 Suharto had made Pancasila, the state's set of founding ideas, the required basis of every group. He kept political Islam in check.
Religion could also rally opposition. In 1986 Cardinal Sin, the Catholic archbishop of Manila, called people onto the streets. He wanted them to protect the soldiers who had broken with Marcos. In Burma, Buddhist monks joined the protests of 1988.
- Thai monarchy
- Revived under Sarit; key in 1973 and 1992.
- Pancasila
- Compulsory for all organisations by 1985.
- Cardinal Sin
- Rallied People Power in 1986.
Real examples to use
Islamic institutions, 1983
Mahathir's government opened Bank Islam Malaysia and the International Islamic University in 1983. It wanted to win Muslim support away from PAS.
Pancasila as the sole basis, 1985
Suharto's laws made every party and mass group adopt Pancasila as its only basis. This limited political Islam.
Worked example: The king's audience, 20 May 1992
In April 1992 General Suchinda, who had led the 1991 coup, became prime minister without being elected. Mass protests followed. From 17 to 20 May troops fired on crowds in Bangkok, and dozens of people were killed.
- Royal act: on 20 May King Bhumibol summoned Suchinda and the protest leader, Chamlong. He urged them to end the conflict.
- Result: the killing stopped, and Suchinda resigned on 24 May. Before he went, an amnesty was issued for those involved in the violence.
- Use: royal support could make or break the legitimacy of any ruler, even a general.
- Judgement: the monarchy was a source of power above the army. But it stepped in after the shooting, not before it.
Watch out for this
Traditional institutions always supported rulers.
They could turn against rulers. The Thai king helped end army rule in 1973 and 1992. The Catholic Church helped bring down Marcos.
Check your understanding
How did the Thai king help end the crisis of May 1992?
- He took over the government himself until new elections were held.
- He called the prime minister and the protest leader to an audience.
- He led a coup with loyal generals.
Show the answer
He called the prime minister and the protest leader to an audience.
Right. The prime minister soon resigned.
Check your understanding
In May 1992 General Suchinda resigned four days after the king summoned him. What does this show about the Thai monarchy?
- The king held a formal power to sack any prime minister he chose.
- Royal support could make or break even a general's right to rule.
- The army had no part in Thai politics by 1992.
Show the answer
Royal support could make or break even a general's right to rule.
Yes. The king's prestige outweighed the army in this crisis.