Government performance

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how Southeast Asian governments held on to power and what this led to.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments in consolidating power in different contexts and over time

Make a guess

Suharto's Indonesia grew about 7 per cent a year for decades. Do you think good economic results guaranteed his survival?

  1. No, he lost a free election in 1997.
  2. No, when the 1997 crisis hit, he fell within a year.
  3. Yes, growth kept him safe until he chose to retire.
Show the answer

No, when the 1997 crisis hit, he fell within a year.

Performance gave strong legitimacy while growth lasted. Economic collapse then helped bring Suharto down in 1998.

Delivering growth, jobs and housing gave governments strong legitimacy. Economic failure often brought rulers down.

Singapore's PAP built its legitimacy on results. Public housing, jobs from foreign investment, and clean, efficient government won steady support.

Suharto's New Order also rested on results. The economy grew by about 7 per cent a year, and by 1984 Indonesia grew enough rice to feed itself. Official poverty fell from about 40 per cent of the people in 1976 to about 11 per cent in 1996.

In Malaysia, the New Economic Policy from 1971 cut poverty from about 49 per cent in 1970 to about 17 per cent in 1990. This helped the Barisan Nasional stay in power.

Failure was dangerous. Under Sukarno, inflation reached about 300 per cent in 1965 and more than 600 per cent in 1966, which weakened him. Under Marcos, debt and corruption led to a severe economic crisis in 1984 and 1985. In Burma, Ne Win cancelled most banknotes in 1987 and wiped out savings. This helped spark the uprising of 1988.

The Asian Financial Crisis of 1997 and 1998 destroyed Suharto's claim to good results. Prices rose, the rupiah collapsed, and he resigned in May 1998.

Indonesian poverty
About 40% (1976) to about 11% (1996).
Malaysian poverty
About 49% (1970) to about 17% (1990).
Burma 1987
Banknotes cancelled; savings wiped out.

Real examples to use

Rice self-sufficiency, 1984

Indonesia produced about 25.8 million tons of rice in 1984 and no longer needed imports. The UN's Food and Agriculture Organization later honoured Suharto for it.

Burma's demonetisation, 5 September 1987

Ne Win's government cancelled the 25, 35 and 75 kyat notes without paying for them. Most of the money in circulation became worthless, and the anger fed the 1988 uprising.

Worked example: Housing Singapore, 1960 to 1990

Singapore's Housing and Development Board (HDB) was set up in 1960. By 1965 it had built 54,430 flats.

  1. Ownership: from 1964 families could buy their flats, which gave them a stake in the country.
  2. Scale: by 1990 most Singaporeans lived in HDB flats.
  3. Link: voters could see the results, and the PAP kept winning elections.
  4. Judgement: visible results built strong legitimacy, but the results had to keep coming.

Watch out for this

Good economic performance guaranteed a government's survival.

Performance legitimacy was strong but fragile. Suharto delivered growth for thirty years but fell within months when the Asian Financial Crisis struck.

Check your understanding

Why did the Asian Financial Crisis threaten Suharto?

  1. It cut him off from American military aid.
  2. It destroyed his main claim to legitimacy, economic success.
  3. It led to a communist uprising that the army failed to stop.
Show the answer

It destroyed his main claim to legitimacy, economic success.

Right. He resigned in May 1998.

Check your understanding

Suharto's Indonesia grew for three decades, yet he fell within a year of the 1997 crisis. What does this show about performance legitimacy?

  1. It never gave Suharto any real support at all.
  2. It protected rulers safely through even the worst economic crisis.
  3. It was strong in good times but collapsed when results failed.
Show the answer

It was strong in good times but collapsed when results failed.

Right. Legitimacy built on results lasted only as long as the results did.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready