What this lesson teaches
I can judge how Southeast Asian governments held on to power and what this led to.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments in consolidating power in different contexts and over time
Make a guess
In February 1986 huge crowds in Manila protested against Marcos. What do you think decided his fall?
- Marcos won a fair election and chose to retire.
- Key army leaders abandoned him and backed the protesters.
- The army crushed the protests and kept him in power.
Show the answer
Key army leaders abandoned him and backed the protesters.
When the defence minister and deputy army chief broke with Marcos, the army would not crush the crowds, and he fled.
In Indonesia, Burma and Thailand the army was the backbone of government. In the Philippines, the army's decision to abandon Marcos helped bring him down.
In Indonesia the army claimed a "dual function" (dwifungsi). It would defend the country and also take part in politics. Under Suharto, officers held seats in parliament and many posts in government and business.
In Burma the army, or Tatmadaw, ruled directly after 1962. Ne Win ruled through a single party, the Burma Socialist Programme Party. Most of its leaders were officers.
In Thailand the army staged coups whenever it felt threatened, as in 1957, 1971, 1976 and 1991. Generals often ruled as prime ministers.
Army power had limits. When the army split, rulers could fall. In February 1986 Marcos's defence minister, Juan Ponce Enrile, turned against him. So did the army's deputy chief, Fidel Ramos. The crowds of People Power protected them.
Army rule rested on force, so it was weak when force was not enough. Thailand's generals had to give way in 1973 and 1992. Mass protests and the king had turned against them.
- Dwifungsi
- Indonesian army's dual role.
- Tatmadaw
- Burma's army; ruled from 1962.
- Defections of 1986
- Enrile and Ramos abandon Marcos.
Real examples to use
Dwifungsi in practice
Under Suharto, serving officers held appointed seats in parliament and ran ministries, provinces and state companies.
Ne Win's party, from 1962
Burma's generals ruled through the Burma Socialist Programme Party, the only legal party from 1964 until 1988.
Defections, 22 February 1986
Defence Minister Juan Ponce Enrile and General Fidel Ramos broke with Marcos. Within four days crowds on EDSA had protected them and Marcos left on 25 February.
Worked example: Burma, 1988: the army holds together
In 1988 protests spread across Burma. A general strike began on 8 August 1988, and huge crowds called for an end to one-party rule.
- Army: on 18 September 1988 the army seized full power as the State Law and Order Restoration Council. Troops fired on protesters, and thousands were killed.
- Unity: unlike Marcos's army in 1986, Burma's officers did not split.
- Result: the generals kept power for decades, but they won no legitimacy.
- Judgement: an army's unity decided whether a ruler survived. Force could keep power, but it could not win acceptance.
Watch out for this
Military rulers could rely on force alone.
Force was not enough when the army split or when protests grew too large. Even military rulers needed legitimacy, through performance, elections or royal support.
Check your understanding
What was dwifungsi in Indonesia?
- The army's "dual function" in defence and politics
- A policy of sharing power with the PKI
- A two-party electoral system run by the army
Show the answer
The army's "dual function" in defence and politics
Right. It justified the army's role in government.
Check your understanding
Mass protests hit both Manila in 1986 and Burma in 1988. Why did Marcos fall while Burma's generals survived?
- Marcos's army split, but Burma's army stayed united.
- The USA sent troops to protect Burma's generals.
- Burma's protests were small, while Manila's were huge.
Show the answer
Marcos's army split, but Burma's army stayed united.
Right. Army unity decided whether the ruler survived.