What this lesson teaches
I can judge how Southeast Asian governments held on to power and what this led to.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments in consolidating power in different contexts and over time
Make a guess
Governments faced communists, ethnic rebels and protesting students. Do you think repression always kept rulers in power?
- No, repression sometimes worked but sometimes brought rulers down.
- No, because governments in the region did not use repression.
- Yes, rulers who were willing to use force kept power.
Show the answer
No, repression sometimes worked but sometimes brought rulers down.
Coldstore weakened Singapore's left, but crackdowns in Thailand in 1973 and the Philippines fuelled opposition that toppled rulers.
Governments faced communists, ethnic rebels, Islamic movements and protesting students. They responded with repression, co-option and reform.
Communists were the main threat in many countries. In 1963 Singapore's PAP broke the left-wing Barisan Sosialis. Its leaders were held in Operation Coldstore. The Philippines fought the New People's Army from 1969.
Ethnic rebels also fought several states. Examples are the Karen and other groups in Burma, and the Moro in the south of the Philippines.
Students and the urban middle class led protests in many places. Examples are Thailand in 1973 and 1992, Manila in 1986, Burma in 1988 and Indonesia in 1998.
Governments used repression, such as detention without trial. Malaysia and Singapore both had an Internal Security Act. In Malaysia's Operasi Lalang in 1987, more than 100 people were detained.
They also used co-option, which means bringing rivals inside the government. Malaysia's Barisan Nasional, formed in 1973 and 1974, took in several former opposition parties.
The Cold War shaped these struggles. Fighting communism gave a reason for repression and brought US support. When the Cold War ended, that reason was harder to use.
- Operation Coldstore
- 1963, Singapore.
- Barisan Nasional
- Formed 1973-1974; absorbed rivals.
- Operasi Lalang
- 1987, Malaysia.
Real examples to use
Operation Coldstore, 2 February 1963
Singapore's police arrested more than 100 people on the left, including party leaders, unionists and students. This crippled the Barisan Sosialis before the 1963 election.
Worked example: Co-opting PAS, 1973 to 1978
PAS, Malaysia's main Islamic opposition party, joined the ruling coalition in 1973. It then became part of the new Barisan Nasional in 1974.
- Gain: for four years UMNO did not have to fight PAS for Malay votes.
- Break: in 1977 PAS split over who should lead Kelantan, and violence broke out. On 8 November 1977 the federal government declared emergency rule there. By December PAS was out of the Barisan Nasional.
- Result: in Kelantan's state election of March 1978, PAS lost power. The winners were the Barisan Nasional and a breakaway party.
- Judgement: co-option tamed a rival for a few years and then weakened it. It lasted while the rival gained from staying inside.
Watch out for this
Repression always kept rulers in power.
Repression worked against small groups, but it failed against mass movements. It failed most when the army or elites split, as in Manila in 1986.
Check your understanding
What is co-option?
- Holding a free and fair election
- Bringing rivals into the government or ruling coalition
- Detaining opponents without trial under security laws
Show the answer
Bringing rivals into the government or ruling coalition
Right. The Barisan Nasional did this.
Check your understanding
PAS sat inside Malaysia's ruling coalition from 1973 to 1977. Which way of handling opposition does this show?
- Reform: changing the constitution to meet the rival's demands.
- Co-option: bringing a rival into the government side.
- Repression: detaining the rival's leaders without trial.
Show the answer
Co-option: bringing a rival into the government side.
Right. PAS was brought inside rather than crushed.