What this lesson teaches
I can judge how Southeast Asian governments held on to power and what this led to.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments in consolidating power in different contexts and over time
Make a guess
Lee Kuan Yew, Suharto and Marcos all held power for many years. Do you think they built their power the same way?
- No, they each relied on Western powers to keep them in office.
- Yes, each relied mainly on loyal generals and the army.
- No: a strong party, the army, or networks of favours.
Show the answer
No: a strong party, the army, or networks of favours.
Lee built the PAP into a disciplined party, Suharto relied on the army, and Marcos used patronage. Their methods shaped how long they lasted.
Leaders built power in different ways: through a strong party, the army, personal charisma or networks of favours. Their choices shaped how long they lasted.
Strong leaders ran most Southeast Asian countries after independence. How they built their power helps explain how long it lasted.
Some built strong parties. Lee Kuan Yew made the People's Action Party (PAP) a disciplined machine. It ran Singapore's government and won every election. In Malaysia, Tunku Abdul Rahman and later Mahathir Mohamad led UMNO inside a coalition of several races.
Some relied on the army. Suharto in Indonesia, Ne Win in Burma and Sarit Thanarat in Thailand were generals. They ruled with army backing.
Some depended on charisma, the personal appeal that draws crowds. Sukarno inspired crowds and balanced the army against the communist party. But he had no strong party of his own.
Some ruled through favours. Marcos put family and friends, his "cronies", in charge of key businesses. This bought loyalty, but it weakened the economy and his right to rule.
Power built on a party or an army usually outlasted power built on one person.
- Party machines
- PAP in Singapore; UMNO in Malaysia.
- Military rulers
- Suharto, Ne Win, Sarit.
- Cronies
- Marcos's friends and relatives in key businesses.
Real examples to use
PAP's party machine, 1968
The Barisan Sosialis boycotted the general election of 13 April 1968. The PAP won all 58 seats, 51 of them unopposed.
Generals in power
Sarit seized power in Thailand in September 1957 and Ne Win in Burma on 2 March 1962. Both then ruled with army backing rather than through elections.
Marcos's personal rule, 1972
Marcos declared martial law in September 1972. His second term was due to end about a year later. He then ruled through family and cronies.
Worked example: Sukarno's fall, 1965 to 1967
Under Guided Democracy Sukarno kept power by balancing the army against the Indonesian Communist Party (PKI). He had no strong party of his own.
- Shock: in 1965 the 30 September Movement failed. The army under Suharto then turned on the PKI and destroyed it.
- Loss: on 11 March 1966 Sukarno signed an order giving Suharto power to restore order.
- End: in March 1967 the People's Consultative Assembly took away Sukarno's powers and named Suharto acting president.
- Judgement: once one side of the balance was gone, charisma alone could not keep Sukarno in power.
Watch out for this
Strong leaders alone explain how governments kept power.
Leaders worked through parties and armies, and they needed legitimacy. When these failed them, even strong leaders fell.
Check your understanding
Why was Sukarno's position weak despite his popularity?
- The Dutch still ruled parts of Indonesia.
- He had no strong party of his own, so he balanced the army against the PKI.
- He had lost his popularity after independence, so the army and parties ignored him.
Show the answer
He had no strong party of his own, so he balanced the army against the PKI.
Right. When that balance broke in 1965, he lost power.
Check your understanding
Lee Kuan Yew's PAP won every seat in 1968, while Sukarno lost power in 1966 and 1967. What best explains the difference?
- Lee had a strong party behind him; Sukarno relied on his own appeal.
- Lee was more popular in Singapore than Sukarno ever was in Indonesia.
- Lee had the army's backing; Sukarno had no army at all.
Show the answer
Lee had a strong party behind him; Sukarno relied on his own appeal.
Right. Power built on a party outlasted power built on one person.