Constitutions and elections

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how Southeast Asian governments held on to power and what this led to.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments in consolidating power in different contexts and over time

Make a guess

Even authoritarian rulers in Southeast Asia held elections. Why do you think they bothered?

  1. Elections gave legitimacy, and they shaped the rules to win.
  2. Because the UN required elections from its member states.
  3. Because they expected and accepted that they might lose.
Show the answer

Elections gave legitimacy, and they shaped the rules to win.

Ruling parties drew boundaries, set rules and limited opponents so that elections confirmed their rule.

Elections gave governments legitimacy, so even authoritarian rulers held them. Ruling parties shaped the rules to make sure they won.

Elections gave governments legitimacy, meaning that people accepted their right to rule. So even authoritarian rulers held them. In Malaysia and Singapore, regular elections were the main source of it. Rival parties could compete, and they sometimes won seats or states.

Ruling parties shaped the rules in their favour. In Malaysia, rural Malay seats had fewer voters than town seats, which helped UMNO. In Singapore, Group Representation Constituencies came in 1988. They made it harder for small opposition parties to win.

Suharto's Golkar won every election from 1971 to 1997. In 1973 the other parties were forced to merge into just two. The government screened their candidates.

Leaders changed constitutions to stay in power. Marcos used martial law to bring in a new constitution in 1973 that gave him wide powers. Mahathir changed Malaysia's constitution in 1983 and 1993 to cut the powers of the Malay rulers.

Elections could also bring rulers down. Burma's generals called an election in 1990 and then ignored the result. This destroyed what was left of their right to rule in people's eyes.

Golkar
Won every election from 1971 to 1997.
Group Representation Constituencies
Singapore, 1988.
Marcos's constitution
1973.

Real examples to use

Golkar's managed wins, 1971 to 1997

Golkar took about 63 per cent of the vote in 1971 and about 75 per cent in 1997. In 1973 the other parties were forced to merge into just two, the PPP and the PDI.

Group Representation Constituencies, 1988

Some seats became team contests. Each team had to include a minority candidate. Small opposition parties found it hard to field a full team.

Burma's ignored election, 27 May 1990

The National League for Democracy won 392 of the seats. The generals refused to hand over power and arrested opposition leaders.

Worked example: Marcos's snap election, February 1986

Marcos called an early presidential election for 7 February 1986 to show he still had support. His rival was Corazon Aquino.

  1. Count: on 9 February, 35 staff walked out of the official vote-count centre. They said the figures on the tally board did not match the computer reports.
  2. Verdict: on 13 February the Catholic bishops declared the result dishonest. Two days later the National Assembly, run by Marcos's party, declared him the winner.
  3. Result: within ten days, army leaders broke with Marcos, and People Power forced him out.
  4. Judgement: an election can give legitimacy, but a stolen one can destroy it.

Watch out for this

Holding elections made a government democratic.

Elections only show democracy when they are free and fair. Golkar's wins in managed elections gave Suharto a show of support, not real competition.

Check your understanding

What did Suharto's government do to political parties in 1973?

  1. It forced them to merge into two parties and screened candidates.
  2. It banned elections and ruled by decree from then on.
  3. It allowed new parties to form freely to divide the opposition.
Show the answer

It forced them to merge into two parties and screened candidates.

Right. This made Golkar's victories certain.

Check your understanding

In February 1986 staff walked out of the vote count, and the bishops called the result dishonest. Why did this matter more than the official result?

  1. It meant the courts would order a new election within a month.
  2. It showed the win was stolen, so Marcos lost his claim to legitimacy.
  3. It proved that Marcos had never held any elections before 1986.
Show the answer

It showed the win was stolen, so Marcos lost his claim to legitimacy.

Yes. A stolen election stripped away the legitimacy it was meant to give.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready