Judging the outcomes of consolidation

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how Southeast Asian governments held on to power and what this led to.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments in consolidating power in different contexts and over time

Make a guess

Suharto ruled Indonesia for 32 years. Do you think a long rule proves a government consolidated power successfully?

  1. Yes, length of rule is the test that matters most.
  2. Not by itself: also judge stability, acceptance and peaceful succession.
  3. No, because elections are the true test.
Show the answer

Not by itself: also judge stability, acceptance and peaceful succession.

Suharto lasted long, but protests and riots during an economic collapse forced him to resign in 1998, with no planned succession. Governments with several sources of legitimacy lasted best.

Some governments kept power for decades; others collapsed. Those that combined several sources of legitimacy lasted longest.

Judge outcomes by clear tests. How long did the government last, and how stable was it? How widely was it accepted? Did power pass on peacefully?

The PAP in Singapore and the Alliance and Barisan Nasional in Malaysia kept power throughout the period. They combined elections, results and control of the opposition.

Suharto lasted 32 years. He combined the army, managed elections, economic growth, anti-communism and US support. He fell when the economy collapsed in 1997 and 1998.

Marcos lasted 20 years but fell in 1986. Economic crisis, the murder of opposition leader Benigno Aquino in 1983, a stolen election and army defections came together.

Burma's army kept power by force, but it lost legitimacy and wrecked much of the economy. Thailand's generals kept taking power but could not hold it against mass protest.

No single source of power was enough. Rulers who relied on one source, such as force or charisma, were the most at risk.

Criteria
Duration, stability, acceptance, peaceful transfer.
Long-lasting
PAP, Barisan Nasional, Suharto.
Collapsed
Sukarno, Marcos, Suharto in 1998.

Real examples to use

Suharto's last months, 1998

The People's Consultative Assembly re-elected Suharto in March 1998. He resigned on 21 May, as the rupiah collapsed and riots spread.

Worked example: Passing on power, 1970 to 1990

A peaceful handover is a strong test of consolidation. It shows that the system can outlast its founder.

  1. Singapore: Lee Kuan Yew handed over to Goh Chok Tong on 28 November 1990. He stayed in the cabinet as Senior Minister, and the PAP kept power.
  2. Malaysia: power passed inside UMNO three times, to Tun Abdul Razak in 1970, Hussein Onn in 1976 and Mahathir in 1981.
  3. Contrast: Marcos in 1986 and Suharto in 1998 left in a crisis, not through a planned handover.
  4. Judgement: party-based systems passed power on smoothly. Rule built around one man ended in crisis.

Watch out for this

A government that stayed in power for a long time had consolidated power successfully.

Length matters, but so does legitimacy. Burma's military stayed in power, but by force and without public acceptance.

Check your understanding

Which government combined several sources of legitimacy most successfully?

  1. The PAP in Singapore
  2. Ne Win's military government in Burma
  3. Sukarno's Guided Democracy in Indonesia
Show the answer

The PAP in Singapore

Right. Elections, performance and control together.

Check your understanding

Lee Kuan Yew handed power to Goh Chok Tong in 1990, and the PAP stayed in government. Which test of consolidation does this pass?

  1. Peaceful transfer: the system outlasted its founding leader.
  2. Force: the army made sure that Goh took over without protest.
  3. Duration: Lee ruled for longer than any other leader in the region.
Show the answer

Peaceful transfer: the system outlasted its founding leader.

Right. A smooth handover shows the system did not depend on one man.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready