K323 / 2027
Thermal properties of matter overview

Lesson 10 of 10

Cooling curves

  • I can sketch and interpret a cooling curve.Syllabus

    Syllabus K323, 9(i). Sketch and interpret a cooling curve.

Make a guess. You are not marked.

Molten wax cools in a test tube. Its temperature stays steady for several minutes while it freezes. What is happening to its energy?

  1. It is still losing energy, released as the particles bond into a solid.
  2. It has stopped losing energy, because its temperature is steady.
  3. It is gaining energy from the air, which balances the cooling.
Show the answer

It is still losing energy, released as the particles bond into a solid.

As the wax freezes, its particles form bonds and release latent heat. That energy replaces what the wax loses to the air, so the temperature stays steady until it is all solid.

A cooling curve records temperature against time. Read each part by asking which state is present and how energy is leaving.

Net heating transfers energy from a hotter region to a cooler one. Temperature falls within a state, but can stay constant during a change of state under the stated conditions.

Interpret a liquid that cools and solidifies

The readings below are model values for a pure substance at fixed pressure. It starts as a liquid, and its solidification temperature is 50°C. Energy keeps leaving the sample the whole time. These are not readings taken from an experiment.

In a school laboratory the substance is often stearic acid, a waxy solid that melts and solidifies at about 69°C. The model values here are for a different substance, one that solidifies at 50°C.

Energy leaves during the solidification plateau

Supplied idealised readings for an unspecified pure substance at fixed pressure. The sample starts as a liquid. These readings illustrate interpretation; they were not collected from an experiment.

Supplied model readings
Time / minTemperature / °C
080
165
250
350
450
535
620
A cooling curve stays at 50 degrees Celsius during solidification from two to four minutesA temperature-time graph shows all seven supplied model readings. At times zero, one, two, three, four, five and six minutes, temperatures are 80, 65, 50, 50, 50, 35 and 20 degrees Celsius. From zero to two minutes the liquid cools. From two to four minutes it solidifies at 50 degrees Celsius. During the transition both liquid and solid are present and energy continues leaving. From four to six minutes the solid cools. A shaded band marks the two-to-four-minute interval, without assigning a numerical solid fraction at three minutes. Straight segments form an idealised model; actual cooling need not have constant slopes.Temperature / °C020406080012345650Solidification50 °CTime / min

0-2 min: the liquid cools from 80 to 50 °C.

2-4 min: liquid changes to solid at 50 °C. During solidification, both states are present.

4-6 min: the solid cools from 50 to 20 °C.

On the plateau, average particle kinetic energy stays unchanged while the interaction potential energy decreases. Internal energy falls as energy continues to leave the sample.

Temperature is plotted up the graph and time along it. The sample cools as liquid, solidifies during the 50°C plateau from 2 to 4 min, then cools as solid. The straight lines are a simple model, not a claim that real cooling rates are always constant.

On the sloping parts, the temperature falls and so does the average random kinetic energy of the particles. During solidification, the amount of solid rises while the amount of liquid falls. Energy still leaves. The potential energy of the particles falls while their average random kinetic energy stays the same.

Worked interpretation

What can be said at 3 min?

The point lies in the solidification part of the curve. Both liquid and solid are present, the temperature is 50°C, and energy is still being transferred out.

The reading does not show that half the sample is solid only because 3 min is halfway between 2 and 4 min. To find that fraction you would need the rate of energy transfer and the energy needed for the whole change of state.

Sketch from the physical stages

  1. Label both axes and units: temperature on the vertical axis, time on the horizontal axis.
  2. Start in the given state: for this liquid, draw a falling temperature towards 50°C.
  3. Mark the change of state: draw the flat part at constant temperature, 50°C, and label it liquid plus solid. As energy keeps leaving, more solid forms.
  4. Carry on after the change of state: once the sample is all solid, draw a falling temperature again.

If you plot readings, place their actual values first. If you sketch without number data, do not invent an exact length of time. Do not make both sloping parts equally steep unless the information supports it.

A cooling gas can condense in the same way. It does so at its condensation temperature for the stated pressure, before the liquid cools further. Identify the change of state you are given. Not every flat part is melting, and a cooling curve need not contain every possible change of state.

Use a temperature probe and data logger

A probe and data logger can record temperature on their own at chosen time intervals. The probe measures the temperature of its sensing region. It does not directly measure heat, latent heat or the internal energy of the whole sample.

  1. Place the sensor: keep its sensing region in good thermal contact with the sample and clear of the base and walls of the vessel. Keep good contact as the sample changes state.
  2. Choose the range and interval: the probe must cover the temperatures of the sample. Pick a sampling interval short enough to show the change of state, and keep the same time zero.
  3. Record and inspect: keep the time units and temperature units, and watch the state of the sample where you can. The graph must show the recorded points, including any scatter.
  4. Judge the response: a slow sensor can round off changes in slope. Recording more often does not make the sensor respond faster.

In the model above, readings only at 1 min and 5 min would miss the whole 2 to 4 min plateau. Sampling more often can reveal it, but cannot fix poor contact or a response time that is too slow.

Real cooling rates may change as the temperature difference from the surroundings changes. A fixed reading from a sensor that is disconnected or badly placed is not evidence of solidification. Check the sensor and the observed state before you give a physical reason for a flat trace.

A flat temperature is not a flat energy account. During this solidification, internal energy falls even though temperature stays constant.

Check your understanding

An idealised cooling curve for a pure substance at fixed pressure is horizontal at 50 degrees C from 2 to 4 min while it solidifies. What happens during that interval?

  1. No energy leaves, because the temperature is not falling while the liquid turns solid.
  2. At 3 min it must be exactly half solid, whatever the transfer rate.
  3. Energy leaves, the amount of solid increases and the particle potential-energy contribution decreases.
Show the answer

Energy leaves, the amount of solid increases and the particle potential-energy contribution decreases.

Solidification transfers energy out while temperature and average random kinetic energy remain unchanged. Liquid and solid coexist during the transition. A plateau does not mean that energy transfer has stopped.