K223 / K224 / 2027
Practical electricity overview

Lesson 5 of 8

Why switches and fuses go in the live wire

  • I can explain why switches, fuses and circuit breakers interrupt the live wire.Syllabus

    Syllabus K223 / K224, 12(i). Explain why switches, fuses and circuit breakers interrupt the live wire.

Make a guess. You are not marked.

A heater is wired with its switch in the neutral wire instead of the live wire. The switch is turned off and the heater stops. Is it safe to touch the heating element?

  1. It is safe as long as the plug is earthed.
  2. Yes. The heater is off, so no current can flow.
  3. No. The element is still connected to live.
Show the answer

No. The element is still connected to live.

Switching the neutral only breaks the return path. The element stays joined to the live wire, so a person touching it can complete a path to earth and get a shock.

In short

  • Switches, fuses and circuit breakers must be in the live wire.
  • Then, when they open, the appliance is cut off from the high voltage.
  • A switch in neutral turns the appliance off but leaves it joined to live. That is dangerous.

A switch, fuse or circuit breaker must be in the live wire. Then, when it opens, it cuts the appliance off from the high voltage.

Live is at a high voltage and neutral is close to 0 V. A switch breaks a circuit by opening a gap in one wire.

Off does not always mean safe

Both circuits have the same a.c. supply and load. Amber shading marks every part still joined to live. It is not a current arrow.

Switch in the live wire

Switch in the live wireAn a.c. supply is on the left, with live at the top and neutral at the bottom. The switch in the live wire is open, so no current flows. Only the live wire on the supply side of the gap is shaded amber. The load is no longer joined to live.LoadA.c.LiveNeutralOpenI = 0

The gap cuts the load off from live. The load is joined only to neutral, which is close to 0 V.

Switch in the neutral wire

Switch in the neutral wireThe same supply and load, but now the open switch is in the neutral wire. The live wire to the load is unbroken. No current flows, so there is no p.d. across the load. The amber shading covers the live wire, the load and the blue wire up to the gap. All of these are still at the live voltage, although the appliance is off.LoadA.c.LiveNeutralOpenI = 0

No current flows, but the load and the blue wire up to the gap are still joined to live. Turning the appliance off has not made it safe.

Both switches stop the current. Only the switch in live cuts the appliance off from live.

A switch in the live wire

When this switch opens, the path from the live supply to the appliance is cut. The appliance is now joined only to neutral, which is close to 0 V. No part of it is at the high voltage.

A switch in the neutral wire

Opening a switch in neutral still stops the current, so the appliance turns off. But the appliance is still joined to live. With no current, there is no p.d. across the element, so all of it is at the live voltage.

Someone who touches it could become a path to earth and get a shock. The danger is easy to miss, because the appliance looks switched off.

Fuses and circuit breakers too

A fuse or circuit breaker cuts the current when there is a fault. It must be in live for the same reason. If a fuse in neutral melted, the appliance would stop working, but it would still be joined to live.

A BS 1363 plug fits a socket only one way round. So its fuse is always on the live side.

Switches around a home

In a home, the lamps and sockets are joined in parallel across live and neutral. Each one gets the full 230 V and can be switched on and off by itself. Singapore homes have separate lighting circuits and socket circuits.

Off does not always mean safe. A switch in the neutral wire stops the current but leaves the appliance at the live voltage.

Check your understanding

In a simple mains appliance circuit, a single-pole switch opens only the neutral wire. The appliance stops operating. Which of these explanations is correct?

  1. Stopping the current makes every part of the appliance have zero potential relative to earth.
  2. The normal current path is broken, but parts of the appliance can remain connected to live.
  3. The protective earth becomes the normal return wire.
Show the answer

The normal current path is broken, but parts of the appliance can remain connected to live.

Opening neutral stops the normal load current, but it does not disconnect the live connection. A single-pole switch belongs in live so that opening it disconnects the appliance from live supply.