Lesson 3 of 6
Separate by solubility and particle size
Dissolve, filter and crystallise to recover the solid you want.
SEC G2 Science K223 / K225 (2027)
I can describe separation methods.Syllabus
Syllabus K223 / K225, 1.2(a). Describe separation methods
I can choose methods from properties.Syllabus
Syllabus K223 / K225, 1.2(b). Choose methods from properties
Separate by solubility and particle size
Filtering removes a solid that does not dissolve; crystallising recovers a solid that does.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A hot solution of copper(II) sulfate holds as much of the solid as it can. It is left to cool. What will you see?
Show the answer
Blue crystals appear, as cold water dissolves less of the solid
Most solids dissolve better in hot water than in cold. As the solution cools, it cannot hold all the solid, so crystals form.
Filtration separates an insoluble solid, one that does not dissolve, from a liquid. Pour the mixture through filter paper in a funnel. The solid left on the paper is the residue. The liquid that passes through is the filtrate. A dissolved solid passes through with the water, because its particles are spread out among the water particles.
To separate two solids, first find a suitable solvent. A solvent is a liquid that dissolves other substances. A suitable one dissolves one solid but not the other. Water dissolves salt but not sand. Iodine hardly dissolves in water but dissolves much better in ethanol, so ethanol can separate iodine from sand.
- Add water and stir
The salt dissolves; the sand does not.
- Filter
The sand is the residue; the salt solution is the filtrate.
- Wash and dry the sand
Pour a little distilled water through the sand to rinse off the salt solution, then dry it.
- Get the salt back
Evaporate the filtrate to dryness, or heat it until saturated and let the salt crystallise.
A saturated solution holds as much dissolved solid as it can at that temperature. To make crystals, heat the filtrate to boil off some water until it is saturated. To test, dip in a glass rod and lift it out: crystals form on it as it cools. Then leave the solution to cool. Most solids dissolve less in cold water, so crystals form. Filter them off, rinse them with a little cold distilled water and dry them between sheets of filter paper. The water is cold so that few crystals dissolve.
Evaporation to dryness boils off all the water. It suits a solid that heat does not harm, such as salt. But it keeps every soluble impurity, an unwanted dissolved substance, in the dry solid. Crystallisation leaves most impurities behind in the remaining solution, so the crystals are purer. Some solids also break down when heated strongly.
Singapore filters its drinking water on a huge scale. At most of the waterworks run by PUB, Singapore's national water agency, the water passes through sand filters. The sand holds back fine insoluble particles. Substances dissolved in the water are not removed this way, just as salt passes through filter paper.
Check your understanding
A clear sugar solution passes through filter paper unchanged. Why?
Show the answer
The sugar is dissolved, so its particles pass through the paper with the water.
Filtration separates insoluble solids from a liquid. Dissolved sugar particles are small and spread through the water, so evaporation or crystallisation is needed to recover the sugar.
Check your understanding
After filtering, the sand on the filter paper is still wet with salt solution. How should you remove the salt from the sand?
Show the answer
Pour a little distilled water through the sand on the paper
The water rinses the salt solution off the sand and carries the dissolved salt through the paper. Dry the sand after washing it.
Watch out for this
A student says: "To get crystals of copper(II) sulfate from its solution, heat the solution until all the water has boiled away." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
That is evaporation to dryness, not crystallisation. Heat only until the solution is saturated, then let it cool so crystals form. Filter them off, rinse them with a little cold distilled water and dry them between filter papers. Boiling to dryness keeps every soluble impurity in the solid, and strong heat can break some salts down. Examiners report heating to dryness as a common misconception in this answer, and say washing the crystals is rarely mentioned.