Lesson 5 of 6
Read the evidence in a chromatogram
Compare spots under the same conditions.
SEC G2 Science K223 / K225 (2027)
I can describe separation methods.Syllabus
Syllabus K223 / K225, 1.2(a). Describe separation methods
I can interpret chromatograms.Syllabus
Syllabus K223 / K225, 1.2(c). Interpret chromatograms
Read the evidence in a chromatogram
Chromatography splits a mixture into spots; on the same paper and solvent, spots at the same height suggest the same substance.
Paper chromatography separates the substances in a mixture, such as the dyes in an ink. Put a small spot of each sample on a start line drawn in pencil near the bottom of the paper. Stand the paper in a beaker with a little solvent, a liquid that dissolves the samples. Keep the start line above the solvent, so the spots do not dissolve into the solvent in the beaker. Use pencil because it does not dissolve; ink would add spots of its own.
The solvent soaks up the paper and carries the substances with it. A substance that dissolves well in the solvent moves far. One that clings to the paper moves less. So a mixture spreads out into separate spots, and the paper becomes a chromatogram. Cover the beaker so the solvent does not evaporate. Before the solvent reaches the top, take out the paper and mark how far the solvent went: the solvent front.
Compare an unknown with standards
Unknown U has two spots at the same heights as one spot in A and one in B.
Several spots show a mixture. One spot suggests a pure substance, but two substances could travel the same distance and make one spot. A spot level with the spot of a known substance suggests they are the same substance. This comparison works only on the same paper, with the same solvent. A spot that stays on the start line does not dissolve in that solvent. So matching spots cannot prove that a sample holds nothing else: another substance could hide under a spot, or be colourless and not show.
The method began with plants. In 1906, the Russian botanist Mikhail Tsvet published how he had separated the colours in leaves. He passed a leaf extract down a tube of powdered chalk, and it split into green, yellow and orange bands. He called the method chromatography. It showed that the green colour of leaves is a mixture of several pigments, or coloured substances.
Check your understanding
U gives two spots that match the spots of A and B. Can you be certain that U contains A and B and nothing else?
Show the answer
No. A and B are probably present, but another substance could hide under a spot.
Matching spots support A and B being present. Another substance could travel the same distance in this solvent and hide under a spot. Or it could be colourless and not show. So the conclusion is not certain.
Check your understanding
Ink X is run with water as the solvent. Two spots move up the paper, but one stays on the start line. What does this show?
Show the answer
One substance in X does not dissolve in water
The solvent carries only substances that dissolve in it. A substance that does not dissolve in water stays where it was spotted.
Watch out for this
A student says: "The start line is drawn above the solvent level so that the line does not dissolve in the solvent." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
The line is in pencil, which does not dissolve anyway. The start line goes above the solvent so that the sample spots do not dissolve off the paper into the solvent in the beaker. If they did, they would not travel up the paper and separate. Examiners report students giving the pencil reason for both choices, when each choice has its own reason.