Skip to notes
K223 / K225 / 2027
Experimental Chemistry

Lesson 2 of 6

Collect a gas using its properties

Solubility and density determine a suitable setup.

SEC G2 Science K223 / K225 (2027)

  • I can select simple experimental setups.Syllabus

    Syllabus K223 / K225, 1.1(b). Select simple experimental setups

Collect a gas using its properties

How well a gas dissolves in water, and whether it is denser than air, decide how you collect it.

First ask: does the gas dissolve in water? If it is insoluble or only slightly soluble, collect it over water. Fill a gas jar with water and turn it upside down in a trough of water. The gas bubbles in and pushes the water out. You can see when the jar is full, even when the gas is colourless.

A very soluble gas would dissolve in the water, so collect it by pushing out air instead. Now density decides. Density is how much mass is packed into a given volume. A gas denser than air sinks, so lead it to the bottom of an upright jar. It pushes the air up and out. This is downward delivery. A gas less dense than air rises, so lead it to the top of an upside-down jar. This is upward delivery.

Choose the collection method
MethodUse it when the gasExamples
Over water (displacement of water)is insoluble or only slightly soluble in waterHydrogen, oxygen
Downward delivery: upright jar, gas enters at the bottomdissolves in water and is denser than airChlorine, hydrogen chloride, sulfur dioxide
Upward delivery: upside-down jar, gas enters at the topdissolves in water and is less dense than airAmmonia
Gas syringemust have its volume measuredAny gas, such as hydrogen from magnesium and acid

Carbon dioxide is only slightly soluble and is denser than air, so it can be collected either over water or by downward delivery. A gas syringe collects a gas and measures its volume. Every join must be airtight, and the plunger must slide freely. The syringe must hold more than the volume of gas expected. Put the bung in straight after the reactants meet, or some gas escapes and the volume measured is too small.

Chemists have long matched the method to the gas. In the 1770s, the English chemist Joseph Priestley collected gases over mercury instead of water. This let him collect and study gases that dissolve in water, such as ammonia. Today mercury is avoided, because its vapour is poisonous.

Check your understanding

Why is collecting ammonia over water unsuitable?

  1. Ammonia is denser than air, so it sinks out of the gas jar before it is sealed.
  2. Ammonia reacts with the glass of the gas jar when the jar is wet with water.
  3. Ammonia is very soluble in water, so much of it dissolves instead of collecting.
Show the answer

Ammonia is very soluble in water, so much of it dissolves instead of collecting.

A very soluble gas is lost into the water. Ammonia is less dense than air, so it is collected by upward delivery into an inverted dry container.

Check your understanding

Hydrogen chloride is very soluble in water and denser than air. How should it be collected?

  1. By downward delivery into an upright gas jar
  2. Over water, in an upside-down gas jar filled with water
  3. By upward delivery into an upside-down gas jar
Show the answer

By downward delivery into an upright gas jar

It dissolves in water, so it must push out air instead. It is denser than air, so it sinks into an upright jar and pushes the air up and out.

Watch out for this

A student says: "Oxygen can be collected over water because it is denser than air." What is wrong with this?

Show the answer

Density has nothing to do with collecting over water. Oxygen can be collected over water because it is only slightly soluble in water, so little of it dissolves. Density matters only when a gas pushes out air. A gas denser than air goes into an upright jar; a gas less dense than air goes into an upside-down jar. Examiners report that giving density here was the most common error, when collecting over water depends on solubility.