Full chapter
Experimental Chemistry
Select apparatus, separate mixtures and judge what measurements actually show.
SEC G2 Science K223 / K225 (2027)
Choose a measurement that answers the question
Choose the apparatus by the quantity you measure and how precise the reading must be.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
You need to measure out 8 cm3 of water. Which gives the more precise reading: a 10 cm3 or a 100 cm3 measuring cylinder?
Show the answer
The 10 cm3 cylinder, as its scale marks are closer together
A small cylinder spreads a small volume up a tall scale, so each mark stands for less. Use the smallest cylinder that holds the volume.
Every measurement starts with two questions. Which quantity changes: time, temperature, mass or volume? And how precise must the reading be? A precise instrument has scale marks close together, so it can show small differences between readings.
| Quantity or task | Apparatus | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Time | Stopwatch | Start and stop it at moments you decide in advance, such as when the acid is added. |
| Temperature | Thermometer or temperature probe | Put the bulb in the mixture itself, not against the hot wall of the container. |
| Mass | Balance | A typical school balance reads to 0.01 g. Zero it with the empty container on it, or subtract the mass of the container. |
| Rough volume of a liquid | Measuring cylinder | Quick, but the least precise. Use the smallest cylinder that holds the volume. |
| One fixed, accurate volume | Volumetric pipette and pipette filler | Delivers exactly the volume it is made for, such as 25.0 cm3. Fill it with the filler, never by mouth. |
| Any accurate volume up to 50 cm3 | Burette | Reads to the nearest 0.05 cm3. Volume delivered = final reading minus initial reading. |
| Volume of a gas | Gas syringe | Collects the gas and shows its volume on a scale. |
Read a liquid level with your eye level with it. Looking from above or below gives a wrong reading, called a parallax error. In a narrow tube, the surface of a liquid curves; this curve is the meniscus. For a clear solution, read the bottom of the meniscus.
In Singapore, the syllabus from SEAB, the national exam board, says to record burette readings to the nearest 0.05 cm3. So write every reading to two decimal places, such as 23.65 cm3. A burette filled to the zero mark reads 0.00 cm3, not 0.
A pipette and a burette are both precise, but they do different jobs. A pipette delivers one fixed volume. A burette delivers any volume up to 50 cm3, so it can measure a volume you do not know in advance. That is why a burette is used in a titration. In a titration, acid runs from the burette into a measured volume of alkali until an indicator just changes colour. The figures in a method also guide you: 25.0 cm3, with its .0, calls for a pipette, not a measuring cylinder.
Check your understanding
A burette reads 1.20 cm3 at the start and 23.65 cm3 at the end. What volume was delivered?
Show the answer
22.45 cm3, the final reading minus the initial reading
23.65 - 1.20 = 22.45 cm3. The final reading is the delivered volume only if the burette started at 0.00 cm3.
Check your understanding
In a titration, acid is added to 25.0 cm3 of alkali until the indicator just changes colour. Which apparatus should add the acid?
Show the answer
A burette, as it measures whatever volume turns out to be needed
The volume of acid needed is not known until the colour changes. A burette adds acid drop by drop and reads any volume to the nearest 0.05 cm3.
Watch out for this
A student says: "A burette is used to add the acid because a burette is accurate." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
This compares nothing, so it does not score. Say what it is more accurate than. A burette measures volume more accurately than a measuring cylinder, because it reads to the nearest 0.05 cm3. Examiners report that "a burette is accurate" on its own is not enough unless it is compared with the measuring cylinder.
Collect a gas using its properties
How well a gas dissolves in water, and whether it is denser than air, decide how you collect it.
First ask: does the gas dissolve in water? If it is insoluble or only slightly soluble, collect it over water. Fill a gas jar with water and turn it upside down in a trough of water. The gas bubbles in and pushes the water out. You can see when the jar is full, even when the gas is colourless.
A very soluble gas would dissolve in the water, so collect it by pushing out air instead. Now density decides. Density is how much mass is packed into a given volume. A gas denser than air sinks, so lead it to the bottom of an upright jar. It pushes the air up and out. This is downward delivery. A gas less dense than air rises, so lead it to the top of an upside-down jar. This is upward delivery.
| Method | Use it when the gas | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Over water (displacement of water) | is insoluble or only slightly soluble in water | Hydrogen, oxygen |
| Downward delivery: upright jar, gas enters at the bottom | dissolves in water and is denser than air | Chlorine, hydrogen chloride, sulfur dioxide |
| Upward delivery: upside-down jar, gas enters at the top | dissolves in water and is less dense than air | Ammonia |
| Gas syringe | must have its volume measured | Any gas, such as hydrogen from magnesium and acid |
Carbon dioxide is only slightly soluble and is denser than air, so it can be collected either over water or by downward delivery. A gas syringe collects a gas and measures its volume. Every join must be airtight, and the plunger must slide freely. The syringe must hold more than the volume of gas expected. Put the bung in straight after the reactants meet, or some gas escapes and the volume measured is too small.
Chemists have long matched the method to the gas. In the 1770s, the English chemist Joseph Priestley collected gases over mercury instead of water. This let him collect and study gases that dissolve in water, such as ammonia. Today mercury is avoided, because its vapour is poisonous.
Check your understanding
Why is collecting ammonia over water unsuitable?
Show the answer
Ammonia is very soluble in water, so much of it dissolves instead of collecting.
A very soluble gas is lost into the water. Ammonia is less dense than air, so it is collected by upward delivery into an inverted dry container.
Check your understanding
Hydrogen chloride is very soluble in water and denser than air. How should it be collected?
Show the answer
By downward delivery into an upright gas jar
It dissolves in water, so it must push out air instead. It is denser than air, so it sinks into an upright jar and pushes the air up and out.
Watch out for this
A student says: "Oxygen can be collected over water because it is denser than air." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
Density has nothing to do with collecting over water. Oxygen can be collected over water because it is only slightly soluble in water, so little of it dissolves. Density matters only when a gas pushes out air. A gas denser than air goes into an upright jar; a gas less dense than air goes into an upside-down jar. Examiners report that giving density here was the most common error, when collecting over water depends on solubility.
Separate by solubility and particle size
Filtering removes a solid that does not dissolve; crystallising recovers a solid that does.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A hot solution of copper(II) sulfate holds as much of the solid as it can. It is left to cool. What will you see?
Show the answer
Blue crystals appear, as cold water dissolves less of the solid
Most solids dissolve better in hot water than in cold. As the solution cools, it cannot hold all the solid, so crystals form.
Filtration separates an insoluble solid, one that does not dissolve, from a liquid. Pour the mixture through filter paper in a funnel. The solid left on the paper is the residue. The liquid that passes through is the filtrate. A dissolved solid passes through with the water, because its particles are spread out among the water particles.
To separate two solids, first find a suitable solvent. A solvent is a liquid that dissolves other substances. A suitable one dissolves one solid but not the other. Water dissolves salt but not sand. Iodine hardly dissolves in water but dissolves much better in ethanol, so ethanol can separate iodine from sand.
- Add water and stir
The salt dissolves; the sand does not.
- Filter
The sand is the residue; the salt solution is the filtrate.
- Wash and dry the sand
Pour a little distilled water through the sand to rinse off the salt solution, then dry it.
- Get the salt back
Evaporate the filtrate to dryness, or heat it until saturated and let the salt crystallise.
A saturated solution holds as much dissolved solid as it can at that temperature. To make crystals, heat the filtrate to boil off some water until it is saturated. To test, dip in a glass rod and lift it out: crystals form on it as it cools. Then leave the solution to cool. Most solids dissolve less in cold water, so crystals form. Filter them off, rinse them with a little cold distilled water and dry them between sheets of filter paper. The water is cold so that few crystals dissolve.
Evaporation to dryness boils off all the water. It suits a solid that heat does not harm, such as salt. But it keeps every soluble impurity, an unwanted dissolved substance, in the dry solid. Crystallisation leaves most impurities behind in the remaining solution, so the crystals are purer. Some solids also break down when heated strongly.
Singapore filters its drinking water on a huge scale. At most of the waterworks run by PUB, Singapore's national water agency, the water passes through sand filters. The sand holds back fine insoluble particles. Substances dissolved in the water are not removed this way, just as salt passes through filter paper.
Check your understanding
A clear sugar solution passes through filter paper unchanged. Why?
Show the answer
The sugar is dissolved, so its particles pass through the paper with the water.
Filtration separates insoluble solids from a liquid. Dissolved sugar particles are small and spread through the water, so evaporation or crystallisation is needed to recover the sugar.
Check your understanding
After filtering, the sand on the filter paper is still wet with salt solution. How should you remove the salt from the sand?
Show the answer
Pour a little distilled water through the sand on the paper
The water rinses the salt solution off the sand and carries the dissolved salt through the paper. Dry the sand after washing it.
Watch out for this
A student says: "To get crystals of copper(II) sulfate from its solution, heat the solution until all the water has boiled away." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
That is evaporation to dryness, not crystallisation. Heat only until the solution is saturated, then let it cool so crystals form. Filter them off, rinse them with a little cold distilled water and dry them between filter papers. Boiling to dryness keeps every soluble impurity in the solid, and strong heat can break some salts down. Examiners report heating to dryness as a common misconception in this answer, and say washing the crystals is rarely mentioned.
Distillation and liquid layers
Distillation boils off the part with the lower boiling point, then cools it back into a liquid.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A mixture of ethanol (boiling point 78 degrees C) and water (boiling point 100 degrees C) is heated slowly in fractional distillation. Which liquid collects first?
Show the answer
Mostly ethanol, as it boils at a lower temperature
Ethanol has the lower boiling point, so its vapour reaches the top of the column first while most water condenses and drips back.
Distillation separates a liquid by boiling it off and then cooling the vapour back into a liquid. Simple distillation gets a solvent back from a solution, such as pure water from salt water. Heat the salt water: the water boils, but the salt does not. The steam passes into a condenser, a tube cooled by a jacket of cold water. There it condenses into pure water, called the distillate. The salt stays in the flask.
Put the thermometer bulb level with the side-arm, so it reads the temperature of the vapour entering the condenser. Cold water enters the condenser at the bottom and leaves at the top. This keeps the jacket full of cold water.
Fractional distillation separates miscible liquids, which mix completely and do not form layers, such as ethanol and water. It works because their boiling points are different: ethanol boils at 78 °C and water at 100 °C. These are too close together for simple distillation to separate them well, so a fractionating column is fitted above the flask.
In the column, vapour condenses and boils again many times. Each time, the vapour gets richer in the liquid with the lower boiling point. So vapour that is mostly ethanol reaches the top, while most of the water condenses and runs back into the flask. The thermometer stays near 78 °C while ethanol distils. When it rises towards 100 °C, most of the ethanol has gone and water is coming over.
Oil refineries use the same idea on a giant scale. Crude oil is a mixture of hydrocarbons, compounds of carbon and hydrogen only. At ExxonMobil's refinery on Jurong Island, Singapore, fractional distillation splits crude oil into fractions. Each fraction is still a mixture of compounds with boiling points in a similar range.
Check your understanding
You need pure water from seawater. Why choose distillation rather than evaporation to dryness?
Show the answer
Distillation condenses and collects the water vapour; evaporation lets it escape.
Both methods boil off the water, but only distillation cools the vapour back into liquid and collects it. Evaporation keeps the salt and loses the water.
Check your understanding
What is the job of the fractionating column when ethanol and water are separated?
Show the answer
It separates the liquids, as most of the water vapour condenses there and runs back
The column gives many rounds of condensing and boiling. So the vapour that leaves the top is rich in ethanol, the liquid with the lower boiling point.
Watch out for this
A student says: "In the fractional distillation of ethanol and water, ethanol distils first because it has a low boiling point." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
Compare the two liquids. Ethanol distils first because its boiling point, 78 degrees C, is lower than that of water, 100 degrees C. "A low boiling point" does not say what it is lower than. Examiners report "has a low boiling point" as the most common error when explaining which liquid is collected first. Write "lower" or "lowest", and say what you are comparing with.
Read the evidence in a chromatogram
Chromatography splits a mixture into spots; on the same paper and solvent, spots at the same height suggest the same substance.
Paper chromatography separates the substances in a mixture, such as the dyes in an ink. Put a small spot of each sample on a start line drawn in pencil near the bottom of the paper. Stand the paper in a beaker with a little solvent, a liquid that dissolves the samples. Keep the start line above the solvent, so the spots do not dissolve into the solvent in the beaker. Use pencil because it does not dissolve; ink would add spots of its own.
The solvent soaks up the paper and carries the substances with it. A substance that dissolves well in the solvent moves far. One that clings to the paper moves less. So a mixture spreads out into separate spots, and the paper becomes a chromatogram. Cover the beaker so the solvent does not evaporate. Before the solvent reaches the top, take out the paper and mark how far the solvent went: the solvent front.
Compare an unknown with standards
Unknown U has two spots at the same heights as one spot in A and one in B.
Several spots show a mixture. One spot suggests a pure substance, but two substances could travel the same distance and make one spot. A spot level with the spot of a known substance suggests they are the same substance. This comparison works only on the same paper, with the same solvent. A spot that stays on the start line does not dissolve in that solvent. So matching spots cannot prove that a sample holds nothing else: another substance could hide under a spot, or be colourless and not show.
The method began with plants. In 1906, the Russian botanist Mikhail Tsvet published how he had separated the colours in leaves. He passed a leaf extract down a tube of powdered chalk, and it split into green, yellow and orange bands. He called the method chromatography. It showed that the green colour of leaves is a mixture of several pigments, or coloured substances.
Check your understanding
U gives two spots that match the spots of A and B. Can you be certain that U contains A and B and nothing else?
Show the answer
No. A and B are probably present, but another substance could hide under a spot.
Matching spots support A and B being present. Another substance could travel the same distance in this solvent and hide under a spot. Or it could be colourless and not show. So the conclusion is not certain.
Check your understanding
Ink X is run with water as the solvent. Two spots move up the paper, but one stays on the start line. What does this show?
Show the answer
One substance in X does not dissolve in water
The solvent carries only substances that dissolve in it. A substance that does not dissolve in water stays where it was spotted.
Watch out for this
A student says: "The start line is drawn above the solvent level so that the line does not dissolve in the solvent." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
The line is in pencil, which does not dissolve anyway. The start line goes above the solvent so that the sample spots do not dissolve off the paper into the solvent in the beaker. If they did, they would not travel up the paper and separate. Examiners report students giving the pencil reason for both choices, when each choice has its own reason.
Use melting and boiling data
A pure substance melts and boils at fixed temperatures, and impurities change them.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
Pure aspirin melts sharply at a fixed temperature. How does a sample of aspirin with a little impurity melt?
Show the answer
Lower, and over a range of temperatures
Impurities lower the melting point and spread the melting over a range. A sharp, correct melting point is evidence of purity.
A pure substance is a single substance with nothing else mixed in. At a given pressure, it melts at one fixed temperature, its melting point. It also boils at one fixed temperature, its boiling point. Data books list these values, so you can compare a measurement with them.
An impurity is an unwanted substance mixed in. It lowers the melting point and makes the solid melt over a range of temperatures. A dissolved impurity raises the boiling point, and the liquid boils over a range. So a sharp melting point that matches the data book suggests a pure sample. It does not prove what the substance is: another substance may melt at the same temperature. A second property, such as the boiling point, makes the identity more certain.
You can see an impurity lower a melting point on icy roads. Each winter, road crews in Minnesota, in the United States, spread salt on icy roads. The salt dissolves in the thin film of water on the ice. Salty water freezes at a lower temperature than pure water, so the ice melts even below 0 °C.
Worked exampleMatch two measurements to reference data
At the same pressure, pure P melts at 18 °C and boils at 126 °C. Pure Q melts at 18 °C and boils at 154 °C. Unknown X melts sharply at 18 °C and boils steadily at 154 °C. A second sample, said to be Q, melts over 12 to 16 °C. Interpret both samples.
Try it first. Then show the worked stepsHide the worked steps
- The melting point alone cannot tell P from Q, because both melt at 18 °C.
- The boiling point of X matches Q, not P. Within the given substances, both measurements support pure Q.
- The second sample melts below 18 °C and over a range. If it is Q, the data show that it contains impurities.
X is consistent with pure Q. The second sample is impure Q if it really is Q; its melting range alone cannot show what it is.
Check your understanding
A liquid is clear and colourless. Is it pure?
Show the answer
Not necessarily. A colourless substance could be dissolved in it.
Many dissolved substances, such as salt or sugar, are colourless. Use a fixed boiling point, chromatography or another test, not appearance.
Check your understanding
At normal pressure, pure water boils at 100 degrees C. A water sample boils between 101 and 103 degrees C. What does this show?
Show the answer
The water contains a dissolved impurity that raises its boiling point
A dissolved impurity raises the boiling point and makes a liquid boil over a range. As water boils off, the solution gets more concentrated, so the temperature keeps rising.
Watch out for this
A student says: "Impure X melts at a higher temperature than pure X, because the impurity makes the solid harder to melt." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
An impurity lowers the melting point. It disrupts the regular arrangement of particles in the solid. So the solid starts to melt at a lower temperature, and it melts over a range instead of at one temperature. It is the boiling point that a dissolved impurity raises. Examiners report students choosing a higher melting point for impure X than for pure X.
Exam-style question
Separate solid Q from sand, then judge the purity of the crystals. [6]
(a) Describe how you would obtain pure, dry crystals of Q from a mixture of Q and sand. [4]
(b) A student's crystals of Q melt over the range 124 °C to 129 °C. What does this show about the crystals? Explain your answer. [2]
Saved on this browser only. Anyone using this browser can see it.
Quick revision
Revisit the essentials, then return to an explanation when you need it.
| Term | Definition to write |
|---|---|
| Pure substance | A single substance that is not mixed with anything else. It melts and boils at fixed (sharp) temperatures. |
| Mixture | Two or more substances that are not chemically combined. They can be separated by physical methods. |
| Residue and filtrate | The residue is the solid left on the filter paper; the filtrate is the liquid that passes through it. |
| Saturated solution | A solution that holds as much dissolved solute as it can at that temperature. |
| Difference | Method |
|---|---|
| Insoluble solid in liquid | Filtration |
| Soluble solid wanted | Crystallisation or suitable evaporation |
| Solvent wanted | Simple distillation |
| Miscible liquids with different boiling points | Fractional distillation |
| Different movement with solvent and paper | Chromatography |
Choose measurements with suitable precision. Distinguish observation from inference. A clear liquid is not automatically pure.
Scope
Learning outcomes
1. Experimental Chemistry (K223 / K225). Use the outcome map to find the explanation for a particular syllabus requirement.
See the learning outcome map
1.1(a) Select measuring apparatus
- Time, temperature, mass and volume
- Burettes, pipettes, measuring cylinders and gas syringes
1.1(b) Select simple experimental setups
- Gas collection
- Suitable apparatus from given information
Choose a measurement that answers the questionCollect a gas using its properties
1.2(a) Describe separation methods
- Solvent, filtration, crystallisation, evaporation
- Simple/fractional distillation
- Paper chromatography
Separate by solubility and particle sizeDistillation and liquid layersRead the evidence in a chromatogram
1.2(b) Choose methods from properties
- Solid-solid
- Solid-liquid
- Miscible liquid-liquid
Separate by solubility and particle sizeDistillation and liquid layers
1.2(c) Interpret chromatograms
- Comparison with known samples
- Rf not required
1.2(d) Infer identity and purity
- Melting and boiling data