Skip to notes
K223 / K225 / 2027
Experimental Chemistry

Lesson 6 of 6

Use melting and boiling data

A physical measurement supports identity; a single match is not proof.

SEC G2 Science K223 / K225 (2027)

  • I can infer identity and purity.Syllabus

    Syllabus K223 / K225, 1.2(d). Infer identity and purity

Use melting and boiling data

A pure substance melts and boils at fixed temperatures, and impurities change them.

Make a guess. You are not marked.

Pure aspirin melts sharply at a fixed temperature. How does a sample of aspirin with a little impurity melt?

  1. Higher, and over a range of temperatures
  2. Lower, and over a range of temperatures
  3. At the same temperature, but more slowly
Show the answer

Lower, and over a range of temperatures

Impurities lower the melting point and spread the melting over a range. A sharp, correct melting point is evidence of purity.

A pure substance is a single substance with nothing else mixed in. At a given pressure, it melts at one fixed temperature, its melting point. It also boils at one fixed temperature, its boiling point. Data books list these values, so you can compare a measurement with them.

An impurity is an unwanted substance mixed in. It lowers the melting point and makes the solid melt over a range of temperatures. A dissolved impurity raises the boiling point, and the liquid boils over a range. So a sharp melting point that matches the data book suggests a pure sample. It does not prove what the substance is: another substance may melt at the same temperature. A second property, such as the boiling point, makes the identity more certain.

You can see an impurity lower a melting point on icy roads. Each winter, road crews in Minnesota, in the United States, spread salt on icy roads. The salt dissolves in the thin film of water on the ice. Salty water freezes at a lower temperature than pure water, so the ice melts even below 0 °C.

Worked exampleMatch two measurements to reference data

At the same pressure, pure P melts at 18 °C and boils at 126 °C. Pure Q melts at 18 °C and boils at 154 °C. Unknown X melts sharply at 18 °C and boils steadily at 154 °C. A second sample, said to be Q, melts over 12 to 16 °C. Interpret both samples.

Try it first. Then show the worked stepsHide the worked steps
  1. The melting point alone cannot tell P from Q, because both melt at 18 °C.
  2. The boiling point of X matches Q, not P. Within the given substances, both measurements support pure Q.
  3. The second sample melts below 18 °C and over a range. If it is Q, the data show that it contains impurities.
Answer

X is consistent with pure Q. The second sample is impure Q if it really is Q; its melting range alone cannot show what it is.

Check your understanding

A liquid is clear and colourless. Is it pure?

  1. Not necessarily. A colourless substance could be dissolved in it.
  2. Yes. An impurity would make the liquid cloudy or coloured.
  3. Not necessarily. Pure liquids are slightly cloudy, so clear means it has been filtered.
Show the answer

Not necessarily. A colourless substance could be dissolved in it.

Many dissolved substances, such as salt or sugar, are colourless. Use a fixed boiling point, chromatography or another test, not appearance.

Check your understanding

At normal pressure, pure water boils at 100 degrees C. A water sample boils between 101 and 103 degrees C. What does this show?

  1. It is a different pure liquid that boils at 101 degrees C
  2. The water contains a dissolved impurity that raises its boiling point
  3. The water is pure but was heated too strongly
Show the answer

The water contains a dissolved impurity that raises its boiling point

A dissolved impurity raises the boiling point and makes a liquid boil over a range. As water boils off, the solution gets more concentrated, so the temperature keeps rising.

Watch out for this

A student says: "Impure X melts at a higher temperature than pure X, because the impurity makes the solid harder to melt." What is wrong with this?

Show the answer

An impurity lowers the melting point. It disrupts the regular arrangement of particles in the solid. So the solid starts to melt at a lower temperature, and it melts over a range instead of at one temperature. It is the boiling point that a dissolved impurity raises. Examiners report students choosing a higher melting point for impure X than for pure X.

Exam-style question

Separate solid Q from sand, then judge the purity of the crystals. [6]

Solid Q dissolves well in water. Sand does not dissolve in water. Pure Q melts at 132 °C.
(a) Describe how you would obtain pure, dry crystals of Q from a mixture of Q and sand. [4]
(b) A student's crystals of Q melt over the range 124 °C to 129 °C. What does this show about the crystals? Explain your answer. [2]

Saved on this browser only. Anyone using this browser can see it.