What this lesson teaches
I can judge how well Southeast Asian governments built national unity in their diverse societies.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments' efforts to build national unity in different contexts and over time
Make a guess
Indonesia's Pancasila made belief in one God a national principle but accepted several religions. What do you think this achieved?
- It made Islam the official religion.
- It kept Muslims, Christians and Hindus within one nation.
- It was ignored, since ideas cannot unite people.
Show the answer
It kept Muslims, Christians and Hindus within one nation.
A national ideology gave diverse peoples shared values, though governments could also use it to silence critics.
National ideologies gave diverse peoples shared values. Religion could unite a majority but alienate minorities.
An ideology is a set of official ideas that all citizens are asked to share. Indonesia's Pancasila set out five principles. They were belief in one God, humanity, national unity, democracy and social justice.
Pancasila did not name one religion. So Muslims, Christians, Hindus and Buddhists could all belong to the nation.
Malaysia set out its Rukunegara on 31 August 1970, after the riots of May 1969. Its five principles included belief in God, loyalty to king and country, and respect for the constitution and the law.
Singapore set out its Shared Values in 1991. They put nation before community and stressed racial and religious harmony.
Religion could unite a majority. In Thailand, the slogan "Nation, Religion, King" joined Buddhism to the monarchy. But tying the nation to one faith pushed others away, such as the Muslims of the south.
In Malaysia, the government promoted Islam from the 1980s. It partly wanted to compete with the Islamic party PAS. This made Malay identity stronger but worried non-Muslims.
- Pancasila
- Five principles; several religions accepted.
- Rukunegara
- Malaysia, 31 August 1970.
- Shared Values
- Singapore, 1991.
Worked example: Pancasila's seven words, June to August 1945
On 22 June 1945, a Committee of Nine agreed a draft preamble, later called the Jakarta Charter. After belief in God, it added seven words. In English they mean "with the obligation to carry out Islamic law for its adherents".
- The objection: Mohammad Hatta later wrote that on the evening of 17 August he got a warning. Christians in eastern Indonesia found the words unfair and might stay out of the new Republic.
- The choice: Hatta persuaded Muslim leaders to give way. On 18 August 1945, the committee preparing independence dropped the seven words.
- The result: the first principle became belief in one God, with no religion named.
- Judgement: a broad ideology helped keep the Christian east in the new state. But Islamic parties tried to bring the words back as late as 2002. The deal had to be defended.
Watch out for this
National ideologies were neutral statements that everyone accepted.
Governments also used them for control. Suharto's laws of 1985 made all parties and mass organisations take Pancasila as their sole basis, which angered some Muslim groups.
Check your understanding
How did Pancasila help unite Indonesia?
- It banned religion from public life.
- It made Islam the official religion.
- It accepted several religions within one nation.
Show the answer
It accepted several religions within one nation.
Right. It avoided making Indonesia an Islamic state.
Check your understanding
From 1985, Indonesian law made all parties and mass organisations take Pancasila as their sole basis. Why did this weaken Pancasila as a tool for unity?
- It made Islam the official religion of the whole of Indonesia.
- It turned a shared ideal into a tool of control.
- It took belief in God out of Pancasila.
Show the answer
It turned a shared ideal into a tool of control.
Right. Some Muslim groups were angered. An ideology unites best when people accept it freely.