The dominant culture approach

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how well Southeast Asian governments built national unity in their diverse societies.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments' efforts to build national unity in different contexts and over time

Make a guess

Thailand built national identity around the Thai language and Buddhism. How do you think minorities responded?

  1. The minority groups accepted it without objection.
  2. Most Chinese assimilated, but southern Malay Muslims resisted.
  3. The minority groups rejected it and rebelled against it.
Show the answer

Most Chinese assimilated, but southern Malay Muslims resisted.

A dominant culture can build a strong identity, but those who feel shut out may resist, as in Thailand's south.

Some governments built unity around the culture of the majority. This could create a strong identity, but minorities often felt shut out.

In a dominant culture approach, the state makes the culture of the largest group the national culture. That means its language, religion and customs. Minorities are expected to adopt it. This is called assimilation.

Thailand put the Thai language and Buddhism at the heart of national identity. Chinese residents were pressed to take Thai names and go to Thai schools. Most of them blended in. But Malay Muslims in the south resisted, and a separatist movement grew.

In Burma, U Nu made Buddhism the state religion in 1961. Christian Kachin and other minorities saw this as forcing Burman culture on them. The Kachin revolt spread.

Indonesia pressed its Chinese minority to blend in after 1966. Chinese schools were closed. Chinese Indonesians were urged to take names that sounded Indonesian.

Malaysia gave Malay culture a special place. Its National Culture Policy of 1971 said the nation's culture should rest on the native culture of the region. In practice this meant Malay culture, with Islam as an important part. Many Chinese and Indians felt like second-class citizens.

Thailand
Thai language, Buddhism and the monarchy at the centre.
Burma, 1961
Buddhism made the state religion.
Indonesia, 1967
Chinese customs kept within the family.

Real examples to use

Southern Thailand, 1947 to 1948

In 1947 Haji Sulong, head of Pattani's Islamic council, asked for Malay to be taught in the first years of school. He also asked for a Muslim governor for the southern provinces. Thai police arrested him in January 1948.

Worked example: Indonesia's Instruction No. 14, 1967 to 1998

On 6 December 1967, Suharto, then acting president, signed an order on the religion and customs of Chinese Indonesians.

  1. The rule: Chinese worship and customs were to be kept within the family. Festivals were not to be held openly in public.
  2. The pressure: a cabinet decision of December 1966 had already urged them to take names that sounded Indonesian. Many did.
  3. The result: they were still treated as outsiders. In the riots of May 1998, Chinese-owned shops and homes were attacked in Jakarta and other cities.
  4. Judgement: forced assimilation changed names and public life. It did not make the majority accept the Chinese as equals.

Watch out for this

The dominant culture approach always failed.

It worked with groups willing to assimilate, such as many Chinese in Thailand. It failed where minorities had a strong separate identity, such as the Malay Muslims of southern Thailand.

Check your understanding

Why did Burma's 1961 state religion law worsen divisions?

  1. It banned Buddhism in schools and the army to please Christian minorities.
  2. Christian and other minorities saw it as forcing a Burman Buddhist identity on them.
  3. It gave minorities independence.
Show the answer

Christian and other minorities saw it as forcing a Burman Buddhist identity on them.

Right. The Kachin rebellion spread.

Check your understanding

Indonesia kept Chinese festivals out of public view from 1967. What do the attacks of May 1998 suggest about this policy?

  1. Most Chinese Indonesians had refused to change their names.
  2. Assimilation had not made the majority accept Chinese Indonesians.
  3. Chinese Indonesians had started a separatist movement.
Show the answer

Assimilation had not made the majority accept Chinese Indonesians.

Right. Thirty years of pressure changed names and public life, but not how the majority saw the minority.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready