What this lesson teaches
I can judge how well Southeast Asian governments built national unity in their diverse societies.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments' efforts to build national unity in different contexts and over time
Make a guess
Indonesia chose Bahasa Indonesia, based on Malay, as its national language, not Javanese, the language of its largest group. Why do you think this worked well?
- It felt neutral, not owned by any one group.
- Because most Indonesians already spoke it at home.
- Because the Dutch had made it the language of government.
Show the answer
It felt neutral, not owned by any one group.
Adopted by nationalists in 1928 and taught in every school, it became a shared language across hundreds of groups.
A shared language and common schooling were powerful tools for unity. Success depended on whether the chosen language felt neutral or belonged to one group.
Indonesia's national language was its greatest success. Bahasa Indonesia, based on Malay, was not the language of the largest group, the Javanese. So no single group could claim it.
Its roots went back before independence. At a youth congress on 28 October 1928, nationalists pledged to "uphold the language of unity, Indonesian". After independence it was taught in schools across the country. It became a shared language across hundreds of groups.
Malaysia made Malay the national language. The National Language Act of 1967 made it the sole official language, though some uses of English were still allowed. From 1970, national schools began to switch to teaching in Malay. Many Chinese and Indians saw this as favouring Malays. They kept their own Chinese and Tamil primary schools.
Singapore chose English as its working language, which no community could claim as its own. From 1966 secondary students also had to learn a second language, usually their "mother tongue". This gave a neutral shared language while keeping cultural roots.
Thailand used Thai-language schooling to absorb minorities. In the Malay-speaking south, Thai schooling was resented. Many families chose Islamic schools, called pondok, instead.
Schools also taught national history, flags and anthems. These built loyalty, though the national story was often the majority's story.
- Youth Pledge
- 28 October 1928: "uphold the language of unity".
- Malaysia
- National Language Act, 1967.
- Singapore
- English plus a mother tongue from 1966.
Real examples to use
Indonesia's constitution, 18 August 1945
Article 36 says, "The language of the State is Indonesian." It was adopted the day after independence was declared.
Worked example: Singapore's schools, 1959 to 1987
In 1959, 27,223 children started Primary 1 in Chinese-medium schools. By 1984 only 260 did, 0.7 per cent of all Primary 1 pupils.
- Parents' choice: most families, Chinese families included, had moved their children to English-medium schools, where English opened more jobs.
- Policy: at the end of 1983, the Ministry of Education said it would merge the language streams from 1984.
- Result: by 1987 English was the first language in all schools, and pupils also studied a mother tongue.
- Judgement: a neutral common language brought pupils of all races into one system. But Chinese-medium schooling, a source of pride for many, came to an end.
Watch out for this
Any national language will unite a country.
A language that belongs to one group can feel like domination to others. Indonesia succeeded partly because its national language was not that of the largest group.
Check your understanding
Why did English work as Singapore's common language?
- No community could claim it as its own, so it was neutral.
- Britain required it as a condition of granting independence in 1963.
- Most Singaporeans spoke it at home in 1965.
Show the answer
No community could claim it as its own, so it was neutral.
Right. It favoured no group.
Check your understanding
Malaysia and Indonesia both chose a form of Malay as the national language. Why did it unite Indonesia more?
- Malaysia never used Malay as a language of teaching in its schools.
- In Indonesia no large group owned it; in Malaysia it was the majority's.
- Indonesia banned all regional languages, so people had no choice.
Show the answer
In Indonesia no large group owned it; in Malaysia it was the majority's.
Right. Many Chinese and Indian Malaysians saw Malay as a Malay privilege, while Indonesians saw Bahasa Indonesia as neutral.