What this lesson teaches
I can judge how well Southeast Asian governments built national unity in their diverse societies.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments' efforts to build national unity in different contexts and over time
Make a guess
After separating from Malaysia in 1965, how do you think Singapore chose to build national unity?
- By making Chinese culture the national culture.
- By leaving each community to live apart with its own schools.
- By recognising its main communities and languages as equal.
Show the answer
By recognising its main communities and languages as equal.
Singapore made Malay, Chinese, Tamil and English official languages and built shared spaces such as mixed housing estates.
Multiculturalism gave each community a recognised place in the nation. Singapore made it the basis of its national identity.
In a multicultural approach, the state treats several cultures as equal parts of the nation. It builds a shared identity on top of them, not in place of them.
Singapore chose this path after the race riots of 1964 and its split from Malaysia in 1965. It kept four official languages: Malay, Chinese, Tamil and English. It treated the main groups as equal.
Singapore also built safeguards. A council set up in 1970 checks most new bills for unfair treatment of any race or religion. In 1973 it was named the Presidential Council for Minority Rights.
Other states mixed approaches. Indonesia's motto, "Unity in Diversity", recognised many cultures. In Malaysia, each main group had a party in the ruling coalition, even while Malay culture had a special place.
This approach had limits. Singapore's system also kept people in fixed racial groups. Some argued that it built up group identities as much as a shared one.
- Singapore's languages
- Malay, Chinese, Tamil and English.
- Ethnic Integration Policy
- 1989: housing quotas.
- Minority rights council
- 1970.
Worked example: Mixing Singapore's housing estates, 1989
By the late 1980s, Malay households made up more than 30 per cent of some neighbourhoods in Bedok and Tampines. Chinese households made up more than 90 per cent of some in Hougang.
- The warning: on 16 February 1989, Minister for National Development S. Dhanabalan presented a new policy to Parliament. He warned that racial enclaves could become "seedbeds for communal agitation".
- The rule: from 1 March 1989, flat sales had to keep each neighbourhood within set limits. These were 84 per cent Chinese, 22 per cent Malay, and 10 per cent Indian and others. Block limits were a little higher.
- The method: unlike the resettlement of the 1960s, nobody was forced to move. The limits only shaped who could get a flat in each place.
- Judgement: Singapore did not leave mixing to chance. It built a shared daily life by rule, at some cost to people's freedom to choose where to live.
Watch out for this
Multiculturalism means the state does nothing to build a common identity.
Singapore actively built shared spaces and values, through housing quotas, bilingual education and national institutions.
Check your understanding
What was the purpose of Singapore's Ethnic Integration Policy of 1989?
- To end public housing and sell flats privately
- To stop ethnic groups clustering in particular housing blocks
- To give one ethnic group priority for new flats
Show the answer
To stop ethnic groups clustering in particular housing blocks
Right. It kept communities mixed.
Check your understanding
A critic says Singapore's multiculturalism kept people in racial boxes. Which fact best supports the critic?
- Singapore made Chinese, the majority's language, its only official language.
- Policies such as housing quotas used fixed racial groups.
- Singapore stopped students learning community languages.
Show the answer
Policies such as housing quotas used fixed racial groups.
Right. Recognising each community also kept race at the centre of daily life.