Why unity was needed: plural societies and separatism

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how well Southeast Asian governments built national unity in their diverse societies.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the outcomes of Southeast Asian governments' efforts to build national unity in different contexts and over time

Make a guess

Indonesia had hundreds of ethnic groups across thousands of islands. Why do you think its government worried about national unity?

  1. Colonial borders had put many peoples inside one state.
  2. It did not, because one shared culture already existed.
  3. Because its peoples had hated each other for centuries.
Show the answer

Colonial borders had put many peoples inside one state.

Independent states inherited plural societies. Governments had to build a shared identity, and some groups wanted to break away.

Colonial borders put many peoples inside one state. Governments needed to build a shared identity, and some groups wanted to break away.

Colonial rulers drew borders to suit themselves. So each new state held many groups, with different languages and religions. Indonesia, for example, had hundreds of ethnic groups on thousands of islands.

Colonial rule also brought in migrants. In Malaya, the Chinese and Indians, most of them from migrant families, made up about half the people in 1957. Chinese traders and firms mattered across the region.

Separatism is a group's campaign to break away and form its own state. Some minorities never accepted rule from the new capital. In Burma, the Karen rose in revolt in 1949. The Kachin and Shan later took up arms too.

Muslims in the southern Philippines and southern Thailand felt shut out by Christian and Buddhist majorities. The Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF) fought for a Muslim homeland in Mindanao from the early 1970s.

In Indonesia, the Free Aceh Movement was founded in 1976. East Timor fought Indonesian rule after Indonesia invaded it in 1975.

Unity mattered for peace, growth and defence. Leaders feared that enemies, including communists, could use these divisions.

Karen rebellion
From 1949.
MNLF
Fought for a Muslim homeland in Mindanao from the early 1970s.
Aceh
Free Aceh Movement founded in 1976.

Real examples to use

Malaya, May 1957

A British minister told Parliament that Malaya had about 3.1 million Malays, 2.5 million Chinese and 0.8 million Indians. Non-Malays were about half the people.

Aceh, 4 December 1976

Hasan di Tiro declared Aceh independent. His Free Aceh Movement drew on anger that Aceh's oil and gas wealth flowed to Jakarta.

Worked example: Burma's union on conditions, 1947 to 1962

Britain had ruled Burma's hill peoples apart from the lowlands, in what it called the Frontier Areas. At Panglong on 12 February 1947, Shan, Kachin and Chin leaders agreed to join a union. Their partner was Aung San, who led Burma's interim government.

  1. The deal: the agreement accepted "full autonomy in internal administration for the Frontier Areas" in principle.
  2. The condition: the constitution of 24 September 1947 let the member states leave the Union, but not for ten years. The Kachin State was left out of this right.
  3. The test: by 1962 Shan and Karenni leaders were claiming that right. Some Shan had taken up arms. The army seized power on 2 March 1962, saying the Union was in danger.
  4. Judgement: the new state rested on a bargain between peoples, not a shared identity. That is why building unity was so urgent.

Watch out for this

Ethnic conflict in Southeast Asia was natural and unavoidable.

Many conflicts grew from colonial borders and from policies after independence that shut minorities out. Policies could ease or worsen them.

Check your understanding

Why did the Karen and other groups rebel in Burma?

  1. They wanted Burma to rejoin the British Empire.
  2. They did not accept rule by a Burman-dominated government.
  3. They were communist parties backed by China.
Show the answer

They did not accept rule by a Burman-dominated government.

Right. They wanted autonomy or independence.

Check your understanding

Burma's 1947 constitution let some states leave the Union after ten years. What does this show about the new state?

  1. Its peoples already shared one strong national identity.
  2. It was a union of peoples on conditions, not yet one nation.
  3. Britain had forced the hill peoples to stay in Burma for ever.
Show the answer

It was a union of peoples on conditions, not yet one nation.

Right. Shan and Karenni leaders later claimed the right to leave, so building unity was urgent.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready