Lesson 9 of 13
Current balance: a graph and its errors
I can explain how a current balance uses conductor force to measure magnetic flux density.Syllabus
Syllabus 9478, 17(h). Explain how a current balance uses conductor force to measure magnetic flux density.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A student uses the whole length of the wire for l, not just the part inside the magnet's field. How does this affect her value of B?
Show the answer
It is too small.
B = F/(Il). Using a length that is too big makes the answer too small.
Take readings at several currents and plot the force against the current. The gradient is Bl, so B = gradient / l.
Keep the length, the angle and the magnet the same. Then F = BlI, so a graph of F against I is a straight line through the origin, with gradient Bl.
| I / A | Reading / g | Change / g | F / mN |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.00 | 150.00 | 0.00 | 0 |
| 0.40 | 150.20 | 0.20 | 1.962 |
| 0.80 | 150.40 | 0.40 | 3.924 |
| 1.20 | 150.60 | 0.60 | 5.886 |
| 1.60 | 150.80 | 0.80 | 7.848 |
Force against current: a straight line
Gradient = 4.905 mN/A = 0.004905 N/A. Divide by the length, 0.0500 m: B = 0.0981 T.
= 4.905 × 10-3 N/A
B = gradient / l = 4.905 × 10-3 / 0.0500
= 0.0981 T
Change mN/A to N/A before you divide. A real graph may not pass through the origin. Do not force the line through it; look for the cause, such as a balance reading that drifts.
Doing the experiment well
- Use a low-voltage supply, and switch off before you change the circuit.
- Measure only the length of wire inside the field, at right angles to it.
- Keep leads and stands clear of the magnet, and run the return wire outside the field.
- Record the reading with no current, and check it again later for drift.
- Take several currents, with repeats. Then reverse the current and repeat.
Look out for these errors. A lead that touches the magnet adds a force of its own. The field is weaker near the edges of the gap, so the length of wire in a uniform field is not sharp. Reversing the current helps you spot a fixed offset, but it does not remove every error.
Readings to 0.01 g can each be out by up to 0.005 g, so their difference can be out by 0.010 g. For a 0.60 g change, that is 0.010/0.60 = 1.7%, before any other errors.
If you use the whole wire, not just the part in the field, l is too big. Then your value of B comes out too small.
Paper 4 practice: spreadsheet
From readings to B in a spreadsheet
In a blank sheet, put the current in A2:A6 and the balance reading in B2:B6, with headings Current / A and Reading / g in row 1. The motion-data page shows how to enter data, copy formulas and make an XY plot.
Put 9.81 in H2 (g in N/kg) and 0.0500 in I2 (the length in m). In C2 enter =(B2-$B$2)/1000, the change in kilograms. In D2 enter =$H$2*C2, the force on the wire in newtons. Fill C2:D2 down to row 6.
Plot D2:D6 against A2:A6 and add a straight line. Do not force it through the origin.
| Cell and quantity | Formula |
|---|---|
| F2: gradient / (N/A) | =SLOPE(D2:D6,A2:A6) |
| G2: intercept / N | =INTERCEPT(D2:D6,A2:A6) |
| J2: B / T | =F2/$I$2 |
Compare your result
The gradient is 0.004905 N/A and the intercept is zero, apart from tiny rounding. J2 gives B = 0.0981 T. This checks your formulas and units. Real readings also need their uncertainty and the drift check above.
Check your understanding
In a current balance, a graph of the force on the wire against the current is a straight line with gradient 2.4 mN/A. The length of wire in the field is 0.040 m. Which of these is the magnetic flux density?
Show the answer
0.060 T
The gradient is Bl. In newtons it is 2.4 x 10-3 N/A, so B = 2.4 x 10-3 / 0.040 = 0.060 T.