8867 / 2027
Quantities and Measurement overview

Lesson 5 of 11

Choosing an instrument and method

  • I can distinguish random and systematic errors, including zero error, and relate them to precision and accuracy.Syllabus

    Syllabus 8867, 1(f). Distinguish random and systematic errors, including zero error, and relate them to precision and accuracy.

Make a guess. You are not marked.

A pendulum swings once in about 2.0 s. Hand timing adds about 0.2 s of uncertainty to any interval. What happens to the percentage uncertainty in the period if you time 20 swings instead of one?

  1. It rises, because there are 20 swings to start and stop
  2. It stays at 10%, because the reaction time is the same
  3. It falls twentyfold, from 10% to 0.5% of the period
Show the answer

It falls twentyfold, from 10% to 0.5% of the period

One swing: 0.2 / 2.0 = 10%. Twenty swings take 40 s with the same 0.2 s, so 0.2 / 40 = 0.5%. Dividing by 20 keeps that 0.5%.

Choose an instrument whose range covers the quantity and whose uncertainty is small enough. Then plan the method around the biggest source of doubt.

The range is the span of values an instrument can measure. The resolution is the smallest change it can show. A fine resolution helps, but the uncertainty of the whole method can still be larger.

A real example. In the 100 m butterfly final at the Rio Olympics on 12 August 2016, Joseph Schooling won Singapore's first Olympic gold in 50.39 s. Michael Phelps, Chad le Clos and László Cseh were all timed at 51.14 s. Times were given to 0.01 s, so the three shared the silver medal.

Instrument choice

Measure a rod about 120 mm long

The uncertainty must be no more than 0.1 mm. Three instruments are available.

Micrometer: range 0 to 25 mm
Reads to 0.001 mm, uncertainty ±0.005 mm. Too short for the rod, however fine it reads.
30 cm ruler: range 0 to 300 mm
1 mm divisions, uncertainty about ±1 mm for this length. Long enough, but not precise enough.
Calipers: range 0 to 150 mm
Reads to 0.01 mm, uncertainty ±0.05 mm here. Long enough and precise enough.

Choose the calipers. Check their zero first, and hold the rod square in the jaws without squeezing it. Quote ±0.05 mm, not ±0.01 mm: the display step is not the whole uncertainty.

Exam questions often tell you to take half the smallest division as the uncertainty. Without that instruction, judge it from the method. Lining up two ends, holding the object still and reaction time can all add to it.

Time many swings, not one

Reaction time adds about the same uncertainty to every hand-timed interval. So time 20 swings and divide by 20. The same timing error becomes a much smaller fraction of the total. Count carefully, and start and stop as the object passes the same marker.

Timing more swings shrinks the effect of reaction time. It does not fix a stopwatch that runs fast. That is a systematic error, which needs calibration.

Check your understanding

A wire is about 0.50 mm thick, and its diameter is needed to within 0.01 mm. Which of these instruments should you use?

  1. A micrometer that reads to 0.01 mm
  2. Calipers that read to 0.1 mm
  3. A metre rule marked in 1 mm divisions
Show the answer

A micrometer that reads to 0.01 mm

Its range covers 0.50 mm and it reads to 0.01 mm, which meets the target. Check its zero error first.

When you calculate a result from readings, carry their uncertainties through with the uncertainty rules.