Lesson 3 of 11
Making estimates
I can make reasonable estimates of physical quantities with stated assumptions.Syllabus
Syllabus 8867, 1(e). Make reasonable estimates of physical quantities with stated assumptions.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A classroom is about 8 m by 6 m by 3 m. Air has a density of about 1.2 kg m-3. Roughly what is the mass of the air in the room?
Show the answer
About 170 kg, as much as three adult people
The volume is 8 x 6 x 3 = 144 m3, so the mass is 1.2 x 144 = 173 kg. Air is light, but a room holds a lot of it.
An estimate is a rough value worked out from simple, stated guesses. It tells you whether an answer is sensible to within a power of ten.
To estimate, pick sensible values you know, say what you assumed, and round the answer. One or two significant figures is enough.
A real example. On 16 July 1945, Enrico Fermi watched the Trinity test, the first nuclear explosion. As the blast wave passed, he dropped small pieces of paper from about six feet up. They were blown about 2.5 m sideways. From that, he estimated the blast was like ten thousand tons of TNT.
Values worth knowing
- Floor area: a classroom is about 8 m by 6 m, so its area is about 50 m2. The product is 48, but rough sides do not justify writing 48.000 m2.
- Mass of an adult: about 50 to 90 kg. Use 60 kg as a working value, and say so.
- Walking: about 1.5 m/s. A 500 m walk takes about 500/1.5 ≈ 300 s, or 5 min.
- Kinetic energy: Ek = ½mv2, with m in kg and v in m/s. A 0.5 kg football kicked at 20 m/s has about ½ × 0.5 × 202 = 100 J.
- Small sizes: 2 µm is 2 × 10-6 m. That is micrometres, not millimetres.
Estimate from a simple shape
Volume, density and pressure of a block
Model a block as about 10 cm by 5 cm by 2 cm, with a mass of about 0.2 kg. These are rough guesses, not measurements.
ρ = m/V ≈ 0.2 / (1 × 10-4) = 2 × 103 kg/m3
Now let it rest on its 10 cm by 5 cm face. Its weight is about mg = 0.2 × 10 = 2 N, using g ≈ 10 N/kg.
p = F/A ≈ 2 / (5 × 10-3) = 400 Pa
The pressure is a few hundred pascals. Notice the two conversions: 1 cm3 = 10-6 m3 for the volume, but 1 cm2 = 10-4 m2 for the area.
Surface area of simple shapes (optional)
Choose the right geometric quantity
Area to cover, area in contact, or volume?
Painting an object means covering its total surface area. Density needs its volume. Pressure needs the area in contact. Decide which you need before choosing a formula.
A triangle needs its perpendicular height
A thin sheet is an isosceles triangle with base 6.00 cm and two sides of 5.00 cm. Cut it down the middle into two right triangles, each with base 3.00 cm. Pythagoras gives the height:
Area = ½ × 6.00 × 4.00 = 12.0 cm2
Use the perpendicular height, not the sloping side. Both faces together are 24.0 cm2, if you ignore the thin edges.
A block has three pairs of faces
For edges l, w and h, V = lwh and the total surface area is S = 2(lw + lh + wh). For the 10 cm by 5 cm by 2 cm block above:
A cylinder has a curved side and two ends
Take a solid cylinder with radius r = 1.00 cm and length L = 10.0 cm. Each end has area πr2. Unrolled, the curved side is a rectangle 2πr wide and L long.
S = 2πrL + 2πr2 = 22π cm2 ≈ 69.1 cm2
If its mass is 50.0 g, its density is 50.0 / (10π) = 1.59 g/cm3. If you measured the diameter d, halve it first: r = d/2.
A sphere uses its radius
A bead has diameter 2.00 cm, so r = 1.00 cm.
V = (4/3)πr3 ≈ 4.19 cm3
The surface is 4πr2, not the flat circle πr2 = 3.14 cm2 that you see from the front. With mass 8.40 g, its density is 8.40 / 4.19 = 2.00 g/cm3.
Check every estimate against common sense. If a classroom floor comes out as 500 000 m2, look for a unit mistake before anything else.
Check your understanding
Which of these is the best estimate of the kinetic energy of an adult walking at a normal pace?
Show the answer
About 70 J
Take a mass of about 60 kg and a walking speed of about 1.5 m/s. Then E = (1/2)mv2 = 0.5 x 60 x 1.52 = 67.5 J, which is about 70 J.