The Singapore-Malaysia water dispute

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge why tensions arose between Southeast Asian states and how they affected the region.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes and consequences of inter-state tensions on inter-state relations and the region

Make a guess

Singapore relied on water from Johor under agreements guaranteed when it separated from Malaysia. How do you think Singapore responded to disputes over price and supply?

  1. It worked towards its own water supply.
  2. It agreed to pay whatever price Malaysia set.
  3. It claimed parts of Johor to secure the water.
Show the answer

It worked towards its own water supply.

Water disputes raised fears for Singapore's survival, so it built reservoirs and new sources to rely less on Johor.

Singapore depended on water from Johor under agreements guaranteed at separation. Disputes over price made water a source of tension and pushed Singapore towards self-sufficiency.

Singapore had few natural sources of fresh water. Under agreements of 1961 and 1962, Johor supplied raw water to Singapore at 3 sen per 1,000 gallons. Singapore sold treated water back to Johor at 50 sen per 1,000 gallons.

The 1961 agreement ran until 2011 and the 1962 agreement runs until 2061. The 1962 agreement lets Singapore draw 250 million gallons a day from the Johor River.

When Singapore left Malaysia in 1965, both governments guaranteed the water agreements in the separation papers. For Singapore, they became part of the basis of its independence.

Water was a weak point. Singapore's leaders feared that the supply could be used to put pressure on them in times of tension.

The two sides could also work together. A 1990 agreement provided for the Linggiu Dam in Johor to make the supply more reliable. Singapore paid more than 300 million Singapore dollars for it, including the land.

Singapore also began to recycle used water and to take the salt out of sea water. It wanted to depend less on Johor.

Agreements
1961 (to 2011) and 1962 (to 2061).
Guarantee
In the separation documents, 1965.
Linggiu Dam
Agreed in 1990.

Worked example: The water talks, 1998 to 2002

From 1998 Singapore and Malaysia negotiated a package of issues, such as railway land in Singapore. Malaysia added a higher price for water to the package.

  1. The price: by Singapore's account, Malaysia's asking price for raw water kept rising. It was 45 sen per 1,000 gallons in August 2000 and 60 sen in February 2001. By September 2002 it was 6.25 ringgit.
  2. The right to review: the agreements allowed a price review after 25 years, but Malaysia did not seek one in 1986 or 1987. Singapore argued that the right had lapsed. Malaysia argued that it could still review.
  3. The break: in October 2002 Malaysia's prime minister, Mahathir, asked to "decouple" water from the other issues. The package talks ended.
  4. Judgement: the quarrel was about a vital resource and about how each side read the agreements. Each government's account defends its own case.

Watch out for this

The water dispute was about territory.

It was about a vital resource, and about how to read the agreements. It was not about borders.

Check your understanding

Why did Singapore treat the water agreements as so important?

  1. They had ended in 1965 and needed replacing.
  2. They were guaranteed in the 1965 separation documents and secured a vital resource.
  3. They gave Singapore control of Johor's rivers, reservoirs and the land around them.
Show the answer

They were guaranteed in the 1965 separation documents and secured a vital resource.

Right. Water was tied to its independence.

Check your understanding

Malaysia did not ask for a price review in 1986 or 1987. Why did this matter later?

  1. The two sides disagreed over whether the right to a review had lapsed.
  2. It meant that Singapore had to pay a higher price from 1987.
  3. It meant that both water agreements had expired in 1987.
Show the answer

The two sides disagreed over whether the right to a review had lapsed.

Right. Singapore said it had lapsed; Malaysia said it could still review.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

  • An American estimate of the Malaysia plan

    Paraphrase of a US Special National Intelligence Estimate, "Prospects for Malaysia", 20 February 1963.

  • An American estimate of confrontation

    Paraphrase of a US National Intelligence Estimate, "The Malaysian-Indonesian Conflict", 30 October 1963.

  • Sukarno explains his position

    Paraphrase of a telegram from the US Ambassador in Jakarta, Howard Jones, reporting a conversation with President Sukarno, 10 April 1964.

  • Malaysia reacts to a Philippine plot over Sabah

    Paraphrase of an intelligence note from the US State Department's Bureau of Intelligence and Research to Secretary of State Rusk, 26 March 1968.

  • Cambodia explains its break with Thailand

    Paraphrase of a US State Department record of a conversation with the Cambodian Ambassador, Nong Kimny, 1 December 1958.

  • The separation agreement guarantees the water agreements

    Paraphrase of section 14 of the Malaysian act annexed to the agreement on the separation of Singapore from Malaysia, signed on 7 August 1965 and registered in the United Nations Treaty Series.

  • an American official on the Manila summit, August 1963

    Extract from a memorandum from Roger Hilsman, Assistant Secretary of State for Far Eastern Affairs, to Secretary of State Dean Rusk, Washington, 2 August 1963, written while the leaders of Indonesia, Malaya and the Philippines were meeting in Manila. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1961-1963, volume XXIII, document 332. A US government document in the public domain.

  • Washington talks to General Nasution, December 1963

    Extract from a telegram from the State Department (signed by Secretary of State Rusk) to the US embassy in Indonesia, 7 December 1963, reporting talks in Washington with General Nasution, Indonesia's Defence Minister, during Konfrontasi. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1961-1963, volume XXIII, document 324. A US government document in the public domain.

  • the President is briefed on the temple ruling, July 1962

    Extract from a memorandum from Carl Kaysen, deputy national security adviser, to President Kennedy, Washington, 12 July 1962, and the volume editors' note on it. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1961-1963, volume XXIII, document 456. A US government publication in the public domain.

  • the State Department on Indonesia's new course, June 1966

    Extract from a State Department paper on Indonesia attached to a memorandum from Walt Rostow to President Johnson, Washington, 8 June 1966, a week after Indonesian and Malaysian delegations led by Adam Malik and Abdul Razak met in Bangkok. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1964-1968, volume XXVI, document 210. A US government document in the public domain.

  • a cartoon about the Manila summit, August 1963

    An original cartoon drawn for these notes in the style of a regional newspaper cartoon published in August 1963, during and after the Manila summit of Indonesia, Malaya and the Philippines, which asked the UN Secretary-General to find out the wishes of the people of Sabah and Sarawak. It is not a copy of a real cartoon.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready