What this lesson teaches
I can judge why tensions arose between Southeast Asian states and how they affected the region.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes and consequences of inter-state tensions on inter-state relations and the region
Make a guess
Indonesia's Sukarno opposed the creation of Malaysia in 1963. How do you think he did it?
- By taking the dispute to the International Court of Justice.
- Through raids, subversion and propaganda, short of full war.
- By declaring full-scale war and invading Malaysia.
Show the answer
Through raids, subversion and propaganda, short of full war.
Konfrontasi used armed raids into Borneo and the peninsula. It ended after Suharto replaced Sukarno.
Indonesia opposed the creation of Malaysia with raids and subversion, short of full war. Konfrontasi ended in 1966, after Suharto replaced Sukarno.
In 1961 Malaya's prime minister, Tunku Abdul Rahman, proposed a new state. It would join Malaya, Singapore and the British territories in Borneo. Britain backed the plan. It could leave its colonies and still keep a friendly, anti-communist state.
Sukarno called Malaysia a British "neo-colonial" plot. He meant that Britain would keep control behind a show of independence. In January 1963 Indonesia began its campaign of Konfrontasi, or confrontation.
Malaysia was formed on 16 September 1963, just after a UN team reported on what people in Sabah and Sarawak wanted. Indonesia and the Philippines would not recognise it.
Indonesia sent armed bands across the Borneo border and set off bombs in Singapore. British and Commonwealth troops defended Malaysia. In January 1965 Indonesia left the UN when Malaysia took a seat on the Security Council.
After the failed coup of 1965, the army under Suharto took power. It lost interest in the campaign. Talks in Bangkok led to a deal in August 1966 that ended Konfrontasi.
- Malaysia formed
- 16 September 1963.
- Indonesia leaves the UN
- January 1965.
- Konfrontasi ends
- August 1966.
Real examples to use
MacDonald House, Singapore, 10 March 1965
Indonesian saboteurs bombed this bank building in Orchard Road. Three people died.
Worked example: Malaysia takes Konfrontasi to the UN, September 1964
In August and September 1964 Indonesian forces landed by sea and by parachute in Johor, on the Malayan peninsula. The fight had spread beyond Borneo.
- The complaint: Malaysia asked for an urgent meeting of the Security Council. It called the parachute drops "a blatant and inexcusable aggression". The debate began on 9 September.
- The vote: on 17 September, nine of the eleven members backed a draft from Norway. It asked both sides to stop all threats and to respect each other's borders and independence.
- The veto: the Soviet Union voted no, and so did Czechoslovakia. As a permanent member, the Soviet Union could block the draft, so it failed.
- Judgement: Cold War splits stopped the UN from acting. So Malaysia relied on British troops and their allies.
Watch out for this
Konfrontasi was a full-scale war between Indonesia and Malaysia.
It was an undeclared, small-scale fight of raids and bombs. Both sides avoided all-out war.
Check your understanding
How did Konfrontasi end?
- After Suharto took power, talks led to an agreement in August 1966.
- Malaysia invaded Indonesian Borneo and forced Sukarno to accept a ceasefire.
- The UN imposed a settlement in 1963.
Show the answer
After Suharto took power, talks led to an agreement in August 1966.
Right. The new leaders wanted peace and Western aid.
Check your understanding
Sukarno called Malaysia a British "neo-colonial" scheme. What did he mean?
- Malaysia planned to make Indonesia its own colony.
- Malaysia was legally a new British colony.
- Britain would keep control behind a show of independence.
Show the answer
Britain would keep control behind a show of independence.
Right. He claimed Malaysia was independent in name only.