What this lesson teaches
I can judge why tensions arose between Southeast Asian states and how they affected the region.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes and consequences of inter-state tensions on inter-state relations and the region
Make a guess
Southeast Asian states quarrelled over Sabah, Preah Vihear and water. Do you think each dispute had a single cause?
- Yes, each was caused by colonial borders.
- No, most combined colonial borders, history, interests and resources.
- No, each was caused by religious differences between neighbours.
Show the answer
No, most combined colonial borders, history, interests and resources.
Colonial-era agreements, old rivalries, national prestige and resources worked together in most disputes.
Tensions arose from colonial borders, rival claims, old rivalries, national ambitions, the Cold War and resources. Most disputes combined several of these causes.
Colonial rule left unclear borders. The claims to Preah Vihear and Sabah both rested on deals made in colonial times.
Old rivalries shaped how states saw each other. Thailand and Cambodia had long been rivals. Singapore and Malaysia split in 1965 after bitter quarrels.
New states also sought power and prestige. Sukarno wanted Indonesia to lead the region. The Philippines wanted a bigger voice in Asia.
The Cold War added suspicion. Britain, the USA and the Soviet Union all took sides in Indonesia's quarrel with Malaysia. Vietnam's invasion of Cambodia in 1978 split the region along Cold War lines.
Resources mattered too. Singapore got much of its water from Johor, so supply was a sore point.
- Colonial legacy
- Disputed borders and agreements.
- Historical animosity
- Thai-Khmer rivalry; the Singapore-Malaysia split.
- Cold War
- Konfrontasi; the Third Indochina War.
Worked example: The Manila agreements, July and August 1963
In mid-1963 the leaders of Malaya, Indonesia and the Philippines met in Manila. They tried to settle their quarrel over the plan for Malaysia. The texts they signed show several causes at once.
- A claim to land: in the Manila Accord of 31 July, the Philippines said its view of Malaysia hung on its claim to Sabah.
- The end of colonial rule: Indonesia and the Philippines would accept Malaysia only if the UN found that the Borneo peoples wanted it.
- Fear of outside powers: a joint statement of 5 August turned to foreign bases. It said they must not be used to undermine the independence of any of the three.
- Judgement: one meeting shows land claims, colonial rule and Cold War fears at work together. No single cause explains the tension.
Watch out for this
Each dispute had a single cause.
Most disputes had several causes. Konfrontasi mixed land, ideology, Sukarno's ambitions and the Cold War.
Check your understanding
Which dispute was mainly about a resource?
- The Preah Vihear temple dispute
- The Philippine claim to Sabah
- The Singapore-Malaysia water dispute
Show the answer
The Singapore-Malaysia water dispute
Right. It concerned the supply and price of water.
Check your understanding
In 1963 the leaders of Malaya, Indonesia and the Philippines agreed that foreign bases must not be used to undermine their independence. Which cause of tension does this show?
- A quarrel over a shared resource such as water
- A rival claim to land along a colonial border
- Suspicion of outside powers in the Cold War
Show the answer
Suspicion of outside powers in the Cold War
Right. Indonesia in particular feared that British bases in Malaya and Singapore could be used against it.