What this lesson teaches
I can judge why tensions arose between Southeast Asian states and how they affected the region.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes and consequences of inter-state tensions on inter-state relations and the region
Make a guess
Konfrontasi and the Sabah quarrel wrecked early regional groupings in the 1960s. What do you think they also led to?
- A military alliance led by Indonesia against Malaysia.
- The end of regional cooperation for decades.
- ASEAN, as ending Konfrontasi made cooperation possible.
Show the answer
ASEAN, as ending Konfrontasi made cooperation possible.
Thai diplomacy helped broker peace in 1966, and ASEAN was founded in 1967 with habits of restraint.
Tensions wrecked early regional groupings, but managing them also pushed states towards ASEAN and its habits of restraint.
Tensions wrecked early attempts at working together. The Sabah dispute and the birth of Malaysia paralysed the Association of Southeast Asia (ASA) in 1963. Konfrontasi killed off Maphilindo.
Ending Konfrontasi made ASEAN possible. Thai Foreign Minister Thanat Khoman helped broker peace between Indonesia and Malaysia in 1966. ASEAN was founded in August 1967.
ASEAN then helped to contain disputes. Members learned to set aside quarrels they could not solve, so that these did not wreck their work together.
Some disputes went to court. In 1998 Indonesia and Malaysia jointly asked the ICJ to decide who owned two small islands, Sipadan and Ligitan. In 2002 the Court gave them to Malaysia.
Security changed too. Konfrontasi kept British and Commonwealth forces in the region. Vietnam's invasion of Cambodia in 1978 drew ASEAN members closer on security.
Overall, tensions split the region, but they also taught its states to handle disputes without war.
- ASA
- Paralysed in 1963.
- Maphilindo
- Collapsed with Konfrontasi.
- ASEAN
- Founded August 1967, after Konfrontasi ended.
Worked example: The Treaty of Amity and Cooperation, 24 February 1976
At their first summit, in Bali, ASEAN's five leaders signed a treaty on how members should treat one another. It came after more than ten years of quarrels.
- The rules: Article 2 listed non-interference in each other's affairs, settling disputes peacefully, and giving up the threat or use of force.
- The means: a High Council of ministers could suggest ways to settle a dispute, such as mediation.
- The limit: Article 16 said the Council could act only if all parties to a dispute agreed. It was not used before 2000.
- Judgement: quarrels taught ASEAN to set rules of restraint. But members still chose to shelve disputes, or later to go to court.
Watch out for this
Tensions between states only harmed cooperation in the region.
They harmed early groups, but ending Konfrontasi led to ASEAN. Later disputes taught members to keep quarrels peaceful.
Check your understanding
How did the end of Konfrontasi help regional cooperation?
- It ended the Sabah dispute with the Philippines as well.
- It reconciled Indonesia and Malaysia, making ASEAN possible in 1967.
- It made Cambodia join ASEAN.
Show the answer
It reconciled Indonesia and Malaysia, making ASEAN possible in 1967.
Right. Thailand helped broker the peace.
Check your understanding
The 1976 treaty let ASEAN's High Council act on a dispute only if all parties agreed. What does this show?
- Members wanted outside powers to settle their disputes.
- ASEAN could order its members to accept its rulings.
- Members guarded their sovereignty and avoided forced settlements.
Show the answer
Members guarded their sovereignty and avoided forced settlements.
Right. ASEAN worked by consent, which limited what its machinery could do.