What this lesson teaches
I can judge why Southeast Asian states set up democratic or authoritarian governments after independence.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that shaped the establishment of different forms of government across Southeast Asia over time
Make a guess
Decolonisation, local elites and the masses, and the Cold War all shaped Southeast Asian governments. Do you think one factor explains every country?
- Yes, the Cold War explains each government in the region.
- No; economic growth alone explains each government.
- No; each factor explains different parts of the story.
Show the answer
No; each factor explains different parts of the story.
Decolonisation set the start, elites made most key choices, the masses forced some changes, and the Cold War shaped outside support.
Decolonisation set the starting point, elites made the key choices, the masses forced some changes, and the Cold War shaped outside support.
The syllabus names three factors. They are the decolonisation experience, the role of local political elites and the masses, and Cold War developments.
Decolonisation explains the institutions each country started with. But it cannot explain later change, such as the Philippines' turn to dictatorship in 1972.
Elites explain most changes in how states were run. Sukarno, Marcos and Ne Win all chose to end elected rule. Thailand's officers staged coup after coup.
The masses explain moments of sudden change. Examples are Thailand in 1973 and 1992, the Philippines in 1986 and Indonesia in 1998.
The Cold War explains why harsh rulers found it easy to justify their power and win foreign support. It also explains why that support faded after the late 1980s.
To compare at least three countries, pick cases that test each factor, such as the Philippines, Indonesia and Malaysia.
- Three factors
- Decolonisation; elites and masses; the Cold War.
- Starting point
- Decolonisation.
- Key choices
- Elites.
Worked example: Testing the factors on one country: the Philippines, 1946 to 1986
The Philippines lets you test all three factors in one country over forty years.
- Decolonisation: independence on 4 July 1946 brought a US-style president, Congress and courts. It explains the starting point only.
- Elites: Marcos ended that system with martial law in 1972, as his last term neared its end.
- Cold War: the USA kept backing him. In June 1981 US Vice President George Bush praised Marcos for his adherence to democratic principles.
- Masses: in February 1986 People Power crowds, joined by rebel army leaders, forced him out.
- Judgement: elite choice explains the big change. The Cold War helps explain how long it lasted, and the masses explain its end.
Watch out for this
One factor explains forms of government in every country.
Different factors mattered more in different countries and periods. Compare cases to show this.
Check your understanding
Which example best tests the decolonisation factor?
- Mass protests that toppled Marcos in the Philippines in 1986
- The Philippines inherited democracy but became a dictatorship in 1972.
- Singapore's public housing programme from 1960
Show the answer
The Philippines inherited democracy but became a dictatorship in 1972.
Right. It shows that decolonisation did not decide later outcomes.
Check your understanding
In 1981 the US Vice President praised Marcos for his adherence to democratic principles, years into his authoritarian rule. Which factor does this support?
- The Cold War, because the USA backed an anti-communist ally.
- The masses, because Filipinos demanded US support for Marcos.
- Decolonisation, because the USA still ruled the Philippines in 1981.
Show the answer
The Cold War, because the USA backed an anti-communist ally.
Right. Washington valued Marcos as an ally more than it cared how he ruled.