What this lesson teaches
I can judge why Southeast Asian states set up democratic or authoritarian governments after independence.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that shaped the establishment of different forms of government across Southeast Asia over time
Make a guess
In 1986 mass protests in Manila helped topple President Marcos. Do you think mass protests always brought democracy?
- Yes, whenever the masses rose up, democracy followed.
- No, elites often decided what came after.
- No, the army took power after the major protests.
Show the answer
No, elites often decided what came after.
In 1986 the protests did restore democracy, but elsewhere, as in Thailand, the army or elites took control again.
Elites usually decided what kind of government was set up. When the masses mobilised, they could topple governments, but elites often decided what came next.
Political elites were the small groups at the top. They included royal families, Western-educated nationalists, landowners and army officers. They led the parties and armies that took power when the colonial rulers left.
Elites often shaped the state to protect their own power. In the Philippines, a few landowning families ran politics. They handed out jobs and favours to win votes. In Thailand, army officers took power in coup after coup.
Some leaders turned away from democracy. In 1959 Sukarno replaced rule by parliament with "Guided Democracy". He said Western-style democracy did not suit Indonesia. In 1972 Marcos declared martial law. He then stayed in power past the end of his second term.
The masses, meaning ordinary people acting together, could change who ruled. In October 1973, student-led protests in Thailand drove out the army rulers. In February 1986, "People Power" protests in Manila forced Marcos out. In 1998, student protests helped end Suharto's rule.
Mass movements did not always win. In 1988 the army crushed a huge uprising in Burma. In 1990 it ignored an election won by Aung San Suu Kyi's party.
- Guided Democracy
- Sukarno, from 1959.
- Martial law
- Marcos, 1972.
- People Power
- February 1986.
Worked example: Thailand, October 1973 to October 1976
In October 1973 huge student-led protests filled Bangkok, and troops fired on the crowds. On 14 October the army rulers Thanom and Praphas gave way, and they soon left the country. The king named a civilian prime minister.
- Masses: students and other people brought down an army government.
- Elites: a new constitution came in 1974. Elections in 1975 and 1976 gave weak governments made up of many parties.
- Reversal: on 6 October 1976 police and right-wing groups attacked students at Thammasat University. Later that day the army took power.
- Judgement: the masses could topple rulers, but the army and other elites decided what lasted.
Watch out for this
Mass protests always brought democracy.
In Burma in 1988 the army crushed the uprising. In Thailand the army came back in 1976 after three years of elected rule.
Check your understanding
What happened in the Philippines in February 1986?
- Marcos declared martial law to stay in power.
- The USA took control of the government in Manila.
- "People Power" protests forced Marcos out of power.
Show the answer
"People Power" protests forced Marcos out of power.
Right. Corazon Aquino became president.
Check your understanding
Students toppled Thailand's military rulers in October 1973, but the army took power again in October 1976. What does this show?
- The students asked the army to return to power in 1976.
- Thailand's student protests never changed who held power in Bangkok.
- The masses could topple rulers, but elites decided what lasted.
Show the answer
The masses could topple rulers, but elites decided what lasted.
Right. The change of 1973 did not survive the coup of 1976.