Patterns across the region over time

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge why Southeast Asian states set up democratic or authoritarian governments after independence.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that shaped the establishment of different forms of government across Southeast Asia over time

Make a guess

Do you think all Southeast Asian countries followed the same path of government after independence?

  1. Yes, they became one-party communist states.
  2. No, they followed two paths, communist or democratic.
  3. No, they followed very different paths.
Show the answer

No, they followed very different paths.

Indonesia moved from democracy to army rule and back; Thailand swung between coups and elections; Indochina became communist.

Southeast Asian governments followed different paths. Comparing them shows which factors mattered where.

Indonesia had rule by an elected parliament from 1950 to 1957. Sukarno's Guided Democracy followed, from 1959 to 1965. Then came Suharto's New Order, backed by the army, from 1966 to 1998. Free elections came back in 1999.

The Philippines was a democracy from 1946 to 1972, though a few rich families ran it. Then it became a dictatorship under martial law. Democracy came back in 1986.

Thailand swung between army rule and elected rule. Army-led rulers fell in 1973 and 1992. A new constitution in 1997 made elected rule stronger.

Burma had an elected parliament from 1948 until Ne Win's coup in 1962. The army then ruled until well after 2000.

Malaysia and Singapore kept holding general elections. Malaysia's one break came after the 1969 riots, when Parliament was suspended until 1971. In Malaysia the Alliance, later the Barisan Nasional, won every general election up to 2000. In Singapore the PAP did. Both used security laws against their rivals.

Indonesia
1950 parliamentary; 1959 Guided Democracy; 1966 New Order; 1999 elections.
Philippines
1946 democracy; 1972 martial law; 1986 restored.
Burma
1948 democracy; 1962 military rule.

Worked example: Indonesia, 1955 to 1959

Indonesia held its first national election on 29 September 1955. Four parties each won between 16 and 23 per cent of the vote. They were the PNI, Masyumi, Nahdlatul Ulama and the communist PKI.

  1. Weakness: no party could rule alone, and cabinets kept falling. Revolts broke out in Sumatra and Sulawesi in 1957 and 1958.
  2. Turn: Sukarno declared martial law in March 1957. On 5 July 1959 he shut the elected assembly that was drafting a new constitution. He brought back the 1945 one instead.
  3. Pattern: a young democracy failed when its parties were split and the army grew strong.
  4. Compare: Burma's elected rule ended in 1962 and the Philippines' in 1972, while Malaysia's elections went on.

Watch out for this

All Southeast Asian countries followed the same path.

Paths differed. Malaysia and Singapore kept holding elections, apart from Malaysia's break of 1969 to 1971, and Burma stayed under army rule. The Philippines, Thailand and Indonesia moved back towards democracy.

Check your understanding

Which country kept regular elections and a dominant party throughout?

  1. Singapore
  2. Burma
  3. Vietnam
Show the answer

Singapore

Right. The PAP won every election.

Check your understanding

Indonesia's 1955 election split the vote between four parties, each with under a quarter. How did this help lead to Guided Democracy?

  1. Weak coalition cabinets kept falling, which Sukarno used to justify change.
  2. The communist PKI won a majority and abolished elections.
  3. The army refused to let the elected parties take their seats.
Show the answer

Weak coalition cabinets kept falling, which Sukarno used to justify change.

Right. Unstable cabinets gave Sukarno his case against party democracy.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready