The decolonisation experience

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge why Southeast Asian states set up democratic or authoritarian governments after independence.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that shaped the establishment of different forms of government across Southeast Asia over time

Make a guess

Malaya gained independence through talks in 1957; Vietnam won it through war. How do you think this shaped their governments?

  1. It made no real difference to how either country was governed.
  2. Talks kept colonial institutions; war gave revolutionaries a claim to rule.
  3. Both became one-party communist states.
Show the answer

Talks kept colonial institutions; war gave revolutionaries a claim to rule.

Malaya got a British-style parliament, while Vietnam's communists built a one-party state from the revolutionary movement.

How a country won independence shaped the government it built. Talks left colonial institutions in place, while wars gave armies and revolutionary leaders a claim to rule.

Where Britain or the USA agreed to leave through talks, they left elected bodies behind. Malaya (1957) and Singapore got a British-style parliament. The Philippines (1946) got an American-style president and Congress.

Power also passed to the elites who had worked with the colonial rulers. In Malaya, the Alliance of Malay, Chinese and Indian parties led the talks. In the Philippines, a few landowning families ran Congress.

Where freedom came through war, armies gained power in politics. Indonesia fought the Dutch from 1945 to 1949. Its army saw itself as the guardian of the nation. In Vietnam, communist forces fought the French, and the communists ruled the North after 1954.

Burma won independence through talks in 1948. But its army had grown out of the fight for freedom. Ethnic revolts split the country, and the army took power in 1962.

Thailand was never a colony. Its 1932 revolution ended the king's absolute power. But power passed to army officers and senior officials, not to elected politicians.

Negotiated
Philippines 1946, Burma 1948, Malaya 1957.
Revolutionary
Indonesia 1945-1949, Vietnam 1945-1954.
Never colonised
Thailand; 1932 revolution.

Real examples to use

Indonesia, 27 December 1949

The Dutch handed over power after four years of fighting and talks. The army that had fought them kept a strong sense of its own role in politics.

Worked example: Malaya's road to independence, 1955 to 1957

Malaya held its first federal election on 27 July 1955. The Alliance of UMNO, the MCA and the MIC won 51 of the 52 elected seats.

  1. Talks: in early 1956 a team led by Tunku Abdul Rahman agreed a target date for independence with Britain in London.
  2. Rules: a commission under Lord Reid drafted the constitution. It kept a British-style parliament and the Malay rulers.
  3. Result: Malaya became independent on 31 August 1957. The same elected coalition was in power.
  4. Judgement: talks handed power to an elected elite that had worked with Britain. In Indonesia, by contrast, the army won its role in politics through war.

Watch out for this

Colonial democratic institutions guaranteed lasting democracy.

The Philippines inherited US-style democracy but came under martial law in 1972. How elites and the army used the institutions mattered more.

Check your understanding

Why did Indonesia's army claim a role in politics?

  1. The UN appointed it to keep order after 1949.
  2. It had fought the Dutch for independence and saw itself as the nation's guardian.
  3. Britain had trained it to govern before handing over power to the generals.
Show the answer

It had fought the Dutch for independence and saw itself as the nation's guardian.

Right. Revolution gave it legitimacy.

Check your understanding

The Alliance won 51 of 52 seats in Malaya's 1955 election and then led the independence talks. What does this show about a negotiated path?

  1. Power passed to an elected elite that had worked with Britain.
  2. Power passed to the army that had fought the British.
  3. Britain kept ruling Malaya through the elected Alliance after 1957.
Show the answer

Power passed to an elected elite that had worked with Britain.

Yes. Talks kept elections and handed power to a cooperating elite.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready