Democratic and authoritarian features

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge why Southeast Asian states set up democratic or authoritarian governments after independence.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 2, Theme I, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the factors that shaped the establishment of different forms of government across Southeast Asia over time

Make a guess

Many Southeast Asian governments held regular elections after independence. Do you think that made them democracies?

  1. Yes, holding elections is what makes a democracy.
  2. No, they did not hold real elections.
  3. Not always; many mixed elections with authoritarian controls.
Show the answer

Not always; many mixed elections with authoritarian controls.

Also check competition, free speech, independent courts and civilian control of the army.

Most Southeast Asian governments mixed democratic and authoritarian features. Judge each one by its elections, competition, freedoms, courts and control of the army.

A democratic state holds free and fair elections. Rival parties can compete and win. People can speak and write freely. Courts are free, and the army obeys elected leaders.

An authoritarian state puts power in one leader, one party or the army. It limits rivals and controls the press. It may jail critics without trial. It may hold elections but fix the result.

Many states in the region were hybrids, a mix of both. Malaysia and Singapore held regular elections, and rival parties took part. But they used laws such as the Internal Security Act to hold opponents without trial. They also limited the press. Suharto's Indonesia held elections from 1971, but the rules made sure his Golkar party won.

Forms of rule changed over time. In the 1950s Indonesia, Burma and the Philippines were democracies. By the early 1970s all three had authoritarian rule. The Philippines moved back towards democracy in 1986, Thailand in 1992, and Indonesia in 1998 and 1999.

Some states were openly authoritarian all along. North Vietnam, and from 1976 all of Vietnam, was run by one communist party. From 1964 Burma was a one-party state run by the army.

Democratic tests
Free elections, competition, freedoms, courts, civilian control.
Hybrids
Malaysia and Singapore: elections plus controls.
Trend
Democracy in the 1950s, authoritarian rule by the 1970s, democratisation from 1986.

Real examples to use

Singapore, 1968 to 1980

The PAP won every seat in Parliament in four general elections in a row, in 1968, 1972, 1976 and 1980.

Worked example: Malaysia, May 1969 to February 1971

In Malaysia's general election of 10 May 1969, opposition parties did well. The ruling Alliance won only 66 of the 104 seats in Peninsular Malaysia, short of two-thirds. Race riots broke out in Kuala Lumpur on 13 May.

  1. Democratic side: voters could cut the ruling side's lead in a real contest.
  2. Authoritarian side: the government declared an emergency and suspended Parliament. A National Operations Council under Tun Abdul Razak ruled until February 1971.
  3. After: when Parliament came back in 1971, it changed the constitution to limit public debate on sensitive issues. One was the special position of the Malays.
  4. Judgement: Malaysia was a hybrid. Its elections were real, but when they shook the ruling side, the state cut back freedoms.

Watch out for this

A country that holds elections is a democracy.

Elections must be free and fair, with real rivals and freedoms. Suharto held elections, but they were run so that Golkar always won.

Check your understanding

Which is an authoritarian feature?

  1. Competitive elections between parties
  2. Detaining critics without trial
  3. Independent courts
Show the answer

Detaining critics without trial

Right. It removes legal protection from opponents.

Check your understanding

In May 1969 Malaysia's ruling Alliance won fewer than two-thirds of the Peninsular seats, and after riots Parliament was suspended until 1971. How does this show a hybrid?

  1. Elections were fake, since the Alliance could not lose seats.
  2. Elections were competitive, but the state then limited freedoms.
  3. Malaysia became a military government once the riots ended.
Show the answer

Elections were competitive, but the state then limited freedoms.

Right. A real contest was followed by emergency rule.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready