What this lesson teaches
I can explain how taxes, subsidies, quotas, tradeable permits, provision, rules and public education correct market failure.
Syllabus 9570, 2.3.3(b). Microeconomic Policies: Policy measures including taxes and subsidies, quotas and tradeable permits, joint and direct provision, rules and regulations, public education in achieving efficiency and equity
Make a guess
A factory knowingly dumps waste into a river. Would a clear label about the damage stop it?
- Yes, if the label is big enough for everyone to see it.
- Yes, because a clear label makes the factory see how much harm it does.
- No. It knows the harm, so it needs a limit or tax.
Show the answer
No. It knows the harm, so it needs a limit or tax.
The cause is a negative externality, not missing information. Labels help when buyers misjudge their own benefit, not when a firm ignores others.
Rules set limits on harmful behaviour; education and labels fix information failure.
Regulation uses rules: bans, limits, standards and required labels. Singapore bans vapes, does not let anyone under 21 buy tobacco, and limits what factories may emit.
Rules act directly and are easy to understand. But they need enforcement, and bans can lead to black markets.
Public education and labels fix information failure. They tell people the true costs or benefits.
Education works slowly, and some people ignore it. So it is often used with taxes or rules.
- Rules
- Bans, limits, standards; need enforcement.
- Education
- Fixes information failure; slow.
Worked example: Energy labels and standards
Since 1 January 2008, air-conditioners and fridges sold in Singapore must carry an energy label with ticks. Since 2011, models below a minimum standard cannot be sold.
- Some buyers look mainly at the price tag. They underestimate how much power a cheap model uses: information failure.
- The tick label shows running costs clearly, so buyers can compare models.
- The minimum standard is a rule. It removes the least efficient models, whatever buyers know.
- Using less power also cuts emissions, a cost to third parties that a label does not price.
Watch out for this
A ban removes all the harm, so it is the best way to deal with a harmful good.
A ban sets the quantity to zero. That is efficient only if every unit costs society more than it is worth. If the external cost is smaller, the ban also stops units that were worth producing.
Check your understanding
Singapore bans the sale and use of vapes. What does the ban need in order to work well?
- A tax on vapes as well, so that they become more expensive.
- Strong enforcement, or a black market will supply vapes illegally.
- Nothing more, because once a good is banned people stop using it.
Show the answer
Strong enforcement, or a black market will supply vapes illegally.
Right. A ban cuts use only if people who break it are likely to be caught. Otherwise illegal sellers step in.