What this lesson teaches
I can explain the causes of market failure: public goods, externalities, information failure, immobile factors and market dominance.
Syllabus 9570, 2.3.2(b). Market Failure and its Causes: Markets may fail in terms of; non-provision of public goods due to non-rivalry and non- excludability; non-socially optimal levels of goods and services due to the presence of externalities, information failure (including asymmetric information), immobility of factors of production, and market dominance
Make a guess
A firm's research gives it new ideas, and other firms soon copy some of them for free. Left alone, how much research will the firm do?
- Less than is best for society, because it ignores the gain to other firms.
- Too much, because research is good for the economy.
- Exactly the right amount, because it pays for all its own research.
Show the answer
Less than is best for society, because it ignores the gain to other firms.
The firm weighs only its own benefit. The gain that spills over to other firms is an external benefit it does not count, so it stops too soon.
When an activity benefits third parties, the free market produces too little of it.
A positive externality is a benefit to third parties that nobody pays for. Vaccination, education and training are examples.
Buyers weigh only their own benefit, the marginal private benefit (MPB). The benefit to society, the marginal social benefit (MSB), adds the marginal external benefit (MEB): MSB = MPB + MEB.
The free market produces where MPB = MPC, at Qp. The efficient output is where MSB = MSC, at Qs. Since MSB is above MPB, Qp is below Qs: the good is underconsumed.
Production can benefit others too. When a firm does research, its ideas spread to other firms through staff who move on and methods others copy. The firm counts only its own gain, so it does less research than is efficient.
This is one reason governments fund research. Under its RIE2025 plan, Singapore set aside about S$25 billion for research and innovation from 2021 to 2025.
Goods like these, which people tend to consume too little of, are often called merit goods.
- MSB
- MPB + MEB.
- Result
- Qp < Qs: underconsumption.
- Example
- Training and SkillsFuture; research grants under RIE2025.
Worked example: SkillsFuture and training
Since January 2016, every Singaporean aged 25 and above has received SkillsFuture Credit to spend on approved courses. The first credit was $500.
- A worker who trains earns more: a private benefit.
- Co-workers and employers gain too, from fewer mistakes and shared skills: external benefits.
- The worker ignores these, so too little training happens: Qp is below Qs.
- The credit lowers the cost of a course, so more people train.
Watch out for this
Education is a merit good, so the government should provide it.
That labels it without explaining. Show the chain: the benefit to others makes MSB higher than MPB, so the market stops at Qp, below Qs. That welfare loss is why the government steps in.
Check your understanding
A flu jab costs $30. It gives the person $25 of benefit and protects others by $15. Will the person buy it, and should society want them to?
- No, and society agrees, because the person's $25 benefit is below the cost.
- Yes, because the total benefit of $40 is more than the $30 cost.
- No, but society should: the $40 total benefit to everyone is above the $30 cost.
Show the answer
No, but society should: the $40 total benefit to everyone is above the $30 cost.
Right. The person weighs only their own $25 against $30 and skips it. Adding the $15 external benefit makes the social benefit $40, above the cost, so too few jabs are bought.