What this lesson teaches
I can explain the causes of market failure: public goods, externalities, information failure, immobile factors and market dominance.
Syllabus 9570, 2.3.2(b). Market Failure and its Causes: Markets may fail in terms of; non-provision of public goods due to non-rivalry and non- excludability; non-socially optimal levels of goods and services due to the presence of externalities, information failure (including asymmetric information), immobility of factors of production, and market dominance
Make a guess
Young adults drink many sugary drinks because they underestimate the long-term health risk. What kind of market failure is this?
- A negative externality, because too much sugar harms people's health.
- Information failure, because buyers misjudge their own benefit.
- No market failure, because adults choose freely what they drink.
Show the answer
Information failure, because buyers misjudge their own benefit.
The harm falls on the drinkers themselves. They overconsume because their perceived benefit is above the actual benefit.
When people misjudge the benefits or costs of a good, they buy the wrong amount.
Information failure happens when people do not know enough to judge the true benefit or cost of what they buy.
Some people overestimate the benefit of a demerit good, such as sugary drinks, because they play down the harm later in life. Their perceived MPB is above the actual MPB, so they consume too much.
Others underestimate the benefit of a merit good, such as health screening, so they consume too little.
This is not an externality. Here the buyer bears the cost or gets the benefit, but misjudges it.
Sort these
Sort each problem by the main source of market failure.
Groups: Negative externality, Positive externality, Information failure, Public good.
- A worker's training also helps co-workers do better.
- A factory's smoke makes nearby residents ill.
- Late-night karaoke keeps neighbours awake.
- Smokers underestimate their own risk of cancer.
- No firm will supply street lighting for a town.
- National defence protects everyone, payer or not.
- Vaccination cuts the spread of flu to others.
- Students overrate how much a costly memory app will lift their grades.
Show the answer
Negative externality
- A factory's smoke makes nearby residents ill. The residents are third parties who bear a cost they did not choose, so the factory overproduces.
- Late-night karaoke keeps neighbours awake. The noise is a cost on people outside the deal, which the singers ignore.
Positive externality
- A worker's training also helps co-workers do better. Co-workers gain without paying, so the worker buys less training than society would want.
- Vaccination cuts the spread of flu to others. Others are protected too, a benefit the person getting vaccinated ignores.
Information failure
- Smokers underestimate their own risk of cancer. The harm falls on the smoker, who misjudges it and buys too much.
- Students overrate how much a costly memory app will lift their grades. They misjudge their own benefit, so they buy more of the app than is worth it to them.
Public good
- No firm will supply street lighting for a town. No one can be stopped from using the light, so people free-ride and no firm can charge.
- National defence protects everyone, payer or not. It is non-excludable and non-rival, so the market would provide none.
- Demerit goods
- Benefit overestimated: overconsumption.
- Merit goods
- Benefit underestimated: underconsumption.
Worked example: Skipping health screening
Screening can find diabetes or some cancers early, when treatment works best. Yet some adults who feel well skip it.
- They judge the benefit by how they feel today, so their perceived MPB is below the actual MPB.
- So they have fewer screenings than they would with full information: Qp is below Qs.
- Healthier SG, launched on 5 July 2023, gives each enrolled resident a family doctor and a health plan.
- The doctor explains which screenings are due, which closes the information gap. Recommended screenings are also free for enrolled citizens.
Watch out for this
Tourists do not realise the damage they do to residents, so this is information failure.
Harm to third parties is an externality, whether or not the buyer knows about it. Information failure is when buyers misjudge their own benefit or cost.
Check your understanding
Buyers overestimate how much a vitamin pill helps them. Compared with full information, how many pills do they buy?
- Fewer, because buyers who are unsure hold back.
- More than is best for them, as they overrate the benefit.
- The best amount, because they pay the full price themselves.
Show the answer
More than is best for them, as they overrate the benefit.
Right. Their perceived MPB is above the actual MPB, so they buy past Qs.