What this lesson teaches
I can explain how taxes, subsidies, quotas, tradeable permits, provision, rules and public education correct market failure.
Syllabus 9570, 2.3.3(b). Microeconomic Policies: Policy measures including taxes and subsidies, quotas and tradeable permits, joint and direct provision, rules and regulations, public education in achieving efficiency and equity
Make a guess
A canteen moves fruit to eye level and puts desserts at the back. Desserts are still on sale. What is this?
- A tax, because desserts become harder to buy.
- A nudge: it changes how the choice is shown.
- A ban, because it discourages desserts.
Show the answer
A nudge: it changes how the choice is shown.
No option is removed and no price changes. Making fruit easier to see steers choices while leaving people free.
A nudge changes how choices are presented, to steer people towards better decisions without removing options.
A nudge uses what we know about cognitive biases to steer choices, without banning any option or changing prices much. H2 names three biases.
Salience bias: people notice what stands out and overlook the rest. Making the key fact prominent, like a large health warning, uses this.
Loss aversion: people feel a loss more strongly than a gain of the same size. Framing a choice as avoiding a loss uses this.
Sunk cost fallacy: people give weight to money they have spent and cannot get back. A small payment up front can make people more likely to turn up to a programme. Nudges are cheap, but their effect can be small, and they must not mislead.
- Nudge
- Changes how a choice is shown, not the options.
- Biases
- Salience, loss aversion, sunk cost fallacy.
Worked example: Plain cigarette packs
Since 1 July 2020, cigarettes in Singapore must be sold in plain packs of a standard colour. Graphic health warnings cover at least 75% of the pack.
- Salience: the warning is the first thing a smoker sees, so the harm is hard to overlook.
- No option is removed: adults can still buy cigarettes, and the packs alone do not change the price.
- So the warning works as a nudge, not as a ban or a tax.
- Judge it by whether fewer people start smoking or more quit, not by how many packs carry it.
Watch out for this
A nudge works on everyone, so it can replace a tax.
Nudges are cheap, but some people stick to habit or comfort, so the effect is often small. They work best alongside price measures and rules.
Check your understanding
Ali paid $200 up front for a gym package he no longer enjoys. He keeps going so that the money is 'not wasted'. Which bias is at work?
- Salience bias: the gym is simply the most noticeable choice he has.
- Loss aversion: he is afraid of losing more money if he stops going.
- Sunk cost fallacy: he gives weight to money he cannot get back.
Show the answer
Sunk cost fallacy: he gives weight to money he cannot get back.
Right. The $200 is spent whatever he does, so it should not affect whether going is worth his time.