Lesson 17 of 17
Energy released in a reaction
I can apply conservation of nucleon number, charge and mass-energy in nuclear processes.Syllabus
Syllabus 9478, 20(n). Apply conservation of nucleon number, charge and mass-energy in nuclear processes.
I can use the mass-energy equivalence E = mc^2.Syllabus
Syllabus 9478, 20(q). Use the mass-energy equivalence E = mc^2.
I can explain how binding energy per nucleon relates to fusion and fission.Syllabus
Syllabus 9478, 20(t). Explain how binding energy per nucleon relates to fusion and fission.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
D-T fusion releases 17.6 MeV from 5 nucleons. A U-235 fission releases about 174 MeV from 236 nucleons. Per kilogram of fuel, which releases more energy?
Show the answer
Fusion, about five times as much.
Per nucleon, fusion gives 17.6/5 = 3.5 MeV and fission 174/236 = 0.74 MeV. Mass goes with the number of nucleons, so fusion gives about five times as much per kilogram.
The energy released in a reaction is its loss of rest mass times c2. Compare the total mass of everything before with everything after, including free neutrons.
Fusion, from masses
Both sides have 5 nucleons and charge +2e. The nuclear masses are 2.01355321 u (deuteron), 3.01550072 u (triton), 4.00150618 u (alpha) and 1.00866492 u (neutron).
Worked fusion energy
Include the neutron
= 0.01888283 u
Q = 0.01888283 × 931.5 = 17.59 MeV ≈ 17.6 MeV
Leaving out the neutron would give 957 MeV, which is impossible.
Fission, from binding energies
Both sides have A = 236 and Z = 92. This is one of many ways uranium-235 can split. Free neutrons have no binding energy, so the energy released is the gain in total binding energy.
| Nucleus | A | MeV per nucleon |
|---|---|---|
| Uranium-235 | 235 | 7.59 |
| Barium-141 | 141 | 8.33 |
| Krypton-92 | 92 | 8.51 |
After: 141 × 8.33 + 92 × 8.51
= 1174.53 + 782.92 = 1957.45 MeV
Q = 1957.45 - 1783.65 = 173.8 MeV ≈ 174 MeV
A real example. ITER, a large fusion experiment, uses the D-T reaction, which "produces a heavier element, helium, and one neutron". It needs about 150 million °C. ITER aims to make 500 MW of fusion power from 50 MW of heating. Its site gives the record so far as JET's 16 MW, from 24 MW of heating, in 1997.
Multiply each per-nucleon value by its own A. Subtracting the per-nucleon values, 8.33 - 7.59, does not give the reaction energy.
Check your understanding
For deuteron + triton -> alpha particle + neutron, supplied nuclear masses are 2.01355321, 3.01550072, 4.00150618 and 1.00866492 u respectively. With 1 u c2 = 931.5 MeV, what is the total released energy?
Show the answer
About 17.6 MeV.
Initial minus final rest mass is 2.01355321 + 3.01550072 - 4.00150618 - 1.00866492 = 0.01888283 u. Multiplying by 931.5 gives 17.5894 MeV.