9478 / 2027
Nuclear Physics overview

Lesson 1 of 17

Evidence for the nucleus

  • I can infer the existence and small size of the nucleus from Rutherford alpha-scattering observations.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9478, 20(a). Infer the existence and small size of the nucleus from Rutherford alpha-scattering observations.

Make a guess. You are not marked.

In the alpha-scattering experiment, a very few alpha particles bounced almost straight back from thin gold foil. What did this show?

  1. The gold atoms are packed so tightly that alpha particles cannot pass.
  2. The positive charge and most of the mass are in a tiny central nucleus.
  3. Electrons in the gold atoms are heavy enough to reflect alpha particles.
Show the answer

The positive charge and most of the mass are in a tiny central nucleus.

Only a very dense, positively charged centre could turn a fast alpha particle right round. That so few did shows the nucleus is tiny compared with the atom.

When alpha particles are fired at thin gold foil, most pass straight through, but a very few bounce back. So an atom must have a tiny, massive, positive nucleus at its centre.

An alpha particle is a fast helium nucleus, with a positive charge. In the experiment, a narrow beam of alpha particles hits a very thin metal foil. A screen around the foil shows where each particle goes.

A narrow beam, a thin foil and a detecting screen

A narrow beam, a thin foil and a detecting screenA shielded alpha source at the left sends a narrow beam through a collimating slit towards a thin foil.αSourceSlitThin foilDetecting screenGuides mark observation directions.Apparatus is schematic.

The screen records where alpha particles arrive. Most go almost straight on. A very few turn through large angles.

Enlarged view: repulsion bends the paths continuously

Enlarged view: repulsion bends the paths continuouslyFour selected model alpha trajectories enter from the left with rightward initial motion and pass a positive nucleus at the centre.Selected enlarged pathsIncident motion is initially rightward.+Positive nucleusNo hard-ball impact is drawn.Paths are not a frequency sample.

The positive nucleus repels the positive alpha particle, so each path bends smoothly. The closer the approach, the larger the turn. The nucleus is not drawn to scale.

The first view shows the source, the foil and the screen. The second zooms in on paths that pass near one nucleus.
What the scattering showed
ObservationWhat it shows
Most alpha particles go straight through, or nearly so.Most of the atom is empty space.
A few turn through large angles.The positive charge is packed into a tiny region, which repels them strongly.
A very few bounce almost straight back.That tiny region also holds most of the atom's mass.

Electrons cannot turn an alpha particle round. An alpha particle is about 7000 times as heavy as an electron. Only a heavy, positive centre can push it back the way it came.

The experiment shows that the nucleus is far smaller than the atom. It does not show that the nucleus contains neutrons; that came later.

A real example. The Nobel Committee's 1951 prize speech tells the story. Ernest Rutherford fired fast helium nuclei from a radium source at atoms. In 1911 he found "that an atom has a positive nucleus which is very small compared to the whole atom". It also holds most of the atom's mass.

Do not say the alpha particles bounced off electrons, or that most of them hit the nucleus. Most passed through because the nucleus is so small. Only the very few that came close were turned back.

Check your understanding

Most alpha particles pass through a thin foil with little deflection, while very few are scattered through large angles or backwards. Which inference is supported?

  1. Large deflections are caused by collisions with individual electrons carrying most of the atomic mass.
  2. The positive nucleus fills most of the atom, and the experiment directly identifies its neutrons.
  3. Positive charge and most atomic mass are concentrated in a small nucleus.
Show the answer

Positive charge and most atomic mass are concentrated in a small nucleus.

Most paths avoid a close approach to the small concentration, while a rare close approach to its positive charge can strongly repel an alpha particle. The observations support a nucleus much smaller than the whole atom.