Lesson 8 of 9
Comparing energy resources
I can compare the named non-renewable and renewable electricity resources in terms of efficiency, cost, reliability and environmental impact.Syllabus
Syllabus K323, 6(g). Compare the named non-renewable and renewable electricity resources in terms of efficiency, cost, reliability and environmental impact.
Make a guess. You are not marked.
A town wants electricity at a steady rate, day and night, whatever the weather. Which resource can supply that on its own?
Show the answer
A nuclear power station, whose fuel releases energy at a controlled rate.
Nuclear fuel releases energy at a rate the operators control, so the output does not depend on wind, sunlight or time of day. Its drawbacks are radioactive waste and high building costs.
Compare energy resources on four points: efficiency, cost, reliability and environmental impact. No resource is best on all four.
Efficiency compares useful output with total input. Power tells how fast energy is transferred. Neither one, on its own, tells you the cost, the reliability or the environmental impact.
Each card below covers one of the eight resources from energy resources for electricity. Read across the same heading in two cards to compare them.
Non-renewable
Fossil fuels
- Efficiency
- Only part of the fuel input becomes electrical output. The rest heats the surroundings. The design of the plant and how it is run change the fraction that is converted.
- Cost
- Count the cost of building the plant, buying and moving fuel, running it, upkeep and pollution controls.
- Reliability
- Output can be controlled when there is fuel and the plant is working. A break in the fuel supply or a shutdown for repairs still matters.
- Environmental impact
- Burning releases carbon dioxide and other pollutants. Getting the fuel out of the ground and moving it also do harm. How much depends on the fuel and the controls used.
Non-renewable
Nuclear fuel
- Efficiency
- The route uses heating, so not all the energy from the fuel becomes electrical output. Count the energy that heats the surroundings.
- Cost
- New plants cost a great deal at the start and take many years to build. Count fuel, running costs, waste handling and taking the plant apart at the end of its life (decommissioning).
- Reliability
- A working plant can give steady electricity. The fuel supply and planned or unplanned shutdowns still affect it.
- Environmental impact
- Making the electricity releases little greenhouse gas, but radioactive waste must be stored safely. Mining, building and decommissioning also matter.
Renewable when the supply is regrown or replaced
Biofuel
- Efficiency
- Compare electrical output with the fuel energy supplied. Heating of the surroundings and other transfers cut the fraction that reaches the electrical output.
- Cost
- Count growing or collecting the material, processing, transport, storage and the generating plant.
- Reliability
- Stored fuel can be used when needed. A lasting supply depends on having enough crops or waste, land and a way to collect or make the fuel.
- Environmental impact
- Burning releases emissions. Land used for fuel crops can cut food production and harm wildlife. Replanting alone does not prove that the whole process is carbon neutral.
Renewable
Wind
- Efficiency
- Compare electrical output with the kinetic energy of the wind that reaches the rotor. The rotor cannot take all of it, and the machinery loses more.
- Cost
- No fuel is bought, but turbines, installation, upkeep and the link to the grid cost money. Changing output can add the cost of storage or backup.
- Reliability
- Output depends on the wind. A windy year on average does not promise the needed output at every moment.
- Environmental impact
- No fuel is burned during generation. Making the turbines, the change to the landscape, noise and harm to birds and bats still need thought.
Renewable
Tides
- Efficiency
- Say whether the input is the energy of moving water or the energy from a difference in water level. Only part reaches the electrical output after the turbine and generator.
- Cost
- Count structures on the coast, turbines, installation, upkeep at sea and the link to the grid.
- Reliability
- The times of the tides can be predicted, but output rises and falls in a cycle. The times of greatest supply need not match the times of greatest demand.
- Environmental impact
- Barrages can change conditions in a river mouth (estuary), habitats and shipping routes. Effects depend on the design and site. A tidal-stream turbine is not the same as a barrage.
Renewable
Hydropower
- Efficiency
- Compare electrical output with the energy of the water going in. Friction and losses in the turbine and generator move some energy to internal stores.
- Cost
- Dams, reservoirs, turbines and links to the grid must be built and kept up. No fuel is burned to supply the water flow.
- Reliability
- A reservoir can control when stored water is let out, within water and environmental limits. Rainfall, seasons and drought change how much water there is.
- Environmental impact
- Dams can change river flow and block fish that travel along the river. Reservoirs may flood land. Harm to habitats and gases from the reservoir depend on the site.
Renewable when the reservoir is managed well
Geothermal reservoirs
- Efficiency
- The route uses energy from a hot fluid. The fraction turned into electricity depends on how hot the fluid is and on the plant design. Some energy goes to the surroundings.
- Cost
- Count the search for a site, drilling, pipes, generating equipment and running costs. The rock below ground must be suitable.
- Reliability
- A suitable, well-managed reservoir can give steady electricity, but not every place has a good enough one.
- Environmental impact
- Think about water use and the effects of drilling. Emissions depend on the plant: a closed system with a second fluid differs from one that lets geothermal gases out.
Renewable
Solar
- Efficiency
- For a photovoltaic panel, compare electrical output with the energy of the sunlight that falls on it. Only part becomes electricity. Use a stated input when you compare it with another kind of plant.
- Cost
- Count panels or thermal equipment, installation, upkeep, the link to the grid and any storage needed. Sunlight itself is not a fuel you buy.
- Reliability
- Photovoltaic output changes with sunlight, clouds and shade, and is zero at night. Storage or another supply can help meet demand at other times.
- Environmental impact
- No fuel is burned when photovoltaic cells run. Making the panels, the materials and disposal still matter. Using roofs that are already there can cut the extra land needed.
Singapore's floating solar farm on Tengeh Reservoir began operating in 2021 and can supply up to 60 MW. It reaches that only in strong sunlight, and it supplies nothing at night.
Give a reason that fits the case. Tides can be predicted but rise and fall in a cycle. A reservoir can hold water back for later. Wind and sunlight vary. These are different kinds of reliability, so do not just call them all "unreliable".
Check your understanding
A coastal town compares tidal power with wind power. Which of these describes their reliability correctly?
Show the answer
Tidal output changes in a predictable cycle, but wind output is hard to predict.
Tides follow a known timetable, so the times of high and low output are known in advance. Wind depends on the weather.