K323 / 2027
Energy overview

Lesson 9 of 9

Choosing a resource for a demand

  • I can compare the named non-renewable and renewable electricity resources in terms of efficiency, cost, reliability and environmental impact.Syllabus

    Syllabus K323, 6(g). Compare the named non-renewable and renewable electricity resources in terms of efficiency, cost, reliability and environmental impact.

The best resource depends on the site and on when the electricity is needed. Support a choice with evidence about both.

Comparing energy resources lists the efficiency, cost, reliability and environmental impact of each resource.

Compare like with like

An efficiency percentage needs a stated input and a stated useful output. A thermal plant's input is fuel energy. A solar panel's input is sunlight. Do not compare the two as if the inputs, and the parts that go unused, cost the same or did the same harm.

Supplied-data comparison

Efficiency is only one of the four points

Two model generators burn fuel. Each receives 1000 J from its fuel in the same length of time. A supplies 350 J electrically; B supplies 450 J. These values show the calculation. They are not figures for a real plant.

  • A: efficiency = 350 / 1000 = 35%.
  • B: efficiency = 450 / 1000 = 45%.

B supplies more electrical energy from the same fuel energy. That result alone does not show which has a lower total cost, does less harm to the environment or gives a steadier supply.

For cost, compare building, fuel, running and upkeep, and any grid, storage or backup needs, over a fair length of time. For reliability, ask whether the needed output is there when it is needed. Think about repairs, weather, season and the supply of fuel or water.

For environmental impact, count building and materials, getting the resource, running the plant, waste, and effects on land and living things. "No fuel burned while it runs" is a smaller claim than "no environmental impact".

A choice changes when the demand changes

Worked explanation

Electricity for a building with suitable roofs

A building has roof space with no shade. It needs a lot of electricity by day and a smaller, steady amount at night. It is connected to an electricity grid.

  1. Match resource to site: photovoltaic panels can use the sunlight that falls on the roofs. Work out the electrical output from the sunlight on hand and how well the panels perform. Do not assume that all the incoming solar energy becomes electricity.
  2. Match supply to time: electricity made by day can help meet the daytime demand. It varies with sunlight and cannot meet the night demand directly, so add stored energy or another supply for the night.
  3. Compare total cost: count installation, upkeep, grid links and any storage needed. Free sunlight does not make the whole system free.
  4. Compare environmental effects: using roofs that are already there can avoid taking up more land, but making the panels, the materials and disposal still matter.

Suppose instead the building must run on its own, with a large steady night demand. Then it needs more storage and backup. So evidence about the demand and the site can change the choice even when the resource is the same.

Do not judge a resource on one point. "Sunlight is free" ignores the cost of panels and storage. "No fuel is burned" ignores how the equipment is made. Give a verdict that weighs the points against the demand.

Check your understanding

A school has suitable unshaded roofs and an electricity demand during both daylight and night. Which of these conclusions about adding solar photovoltaic panels is supported?

  1. Free sunlight makes the panels 100% efficient, so the electricity they produce costs nothing.
  2. They can contribute to daylight demand; night demand requires stored energy or another supply.
  3. Their renewable supply means they deliver a steady power through the day and the night.
Show the answer

They can contribute to daylight demand; night demand requires stored energy or another supply.

This connects the resource to the demand pattern. The roof area, expected daytime generation, costs and environmental effects still need comparison, while the night-time supply must be provided explicitly.