Lesson 4 of 4
Turn observations into a justified conclusion
Use independent evidence and distinguish uncertainty from absence.
O-Level 5086 / 5088 (2026) / SEC G3 K326 / K328 (2027)
I can identify aqueous cations.Syllabus
Syllabus K326 / K328, 6(a). Identify aqueous cations
I can identify anions.Syllabus
Syllabus K326 / K328, 6(b). Identify anions
Turn observations into a justified conclusion
Record each observation first, then combine the cation and anion results to name the whole compound.
An observation is what you see, such as a colour change, a precipitate or effervescence (fizzing). A conclusion is what you work out from it, such as the name of an ion. Mark schemes give a mark for each, so write them separately. To name an unknown compound, test for its cation and its anion, then put the two results together.
| Write this | Not this | Why |
|---|---|---|
| White precipitate | Cloudy; chalky; milky precipitate | Examiners list these as errors. "Milky" was accepted for limewater, but even there "white precipitate" is safer. |
| White precipitate, soluble in excess, giving a colourless solution | A soluble precipitate | Examiners call this unclear. Say what forms first, what happens in excess and the colour of the final solution. |
| Effervescence; the gas gives a white precipitate with limewater | A gas is produced | This is not an observation. You see effervescence; the limewater result shows that the gas is carbon dioxide. |
| Damp red litmus paper turns blue: the gas is ammonia | Damp red litmus paper turns blue | When a question asks for the gas, name it. Many answers give only the litmus result. |
| Purple to colourless | Goes clear | Give the colour before and after. Clear means see-through, and a coloured solution can be clear too. |
Worked exampleIdentify a dissolved salt
Fresh portions of a solution are tested. Aqueous sodium hydroxide gives a green precipitate, insoluble in excess. Dilute nitric acid and aqueous barium nitrate give a white precipitate. Identify the salt.
Try it first. Then show the worked stepsHide the worked steps
- The green precipitate shows Fe2+. Fe3+ would give a red-brown precipitate.
- The white precipitate with acidified barium nitrate shows SO42-.
- Fe2+ and SO42- have equal and opposite charges, so they combine one to one: FeSO4.
The salt is iron(II) sulfate, FeSO4. Write the observations first, then this conclusion.
A negative result, such as "no precipitate", is still an observation, so write it down rather than leave a blank. Use it with care. No precipitate with aqueous ammonia fits calcium, not zinc, but a very dilute sample can also hide a precipitate. The exam may use an ion that is not in the printed notes. You need not name it: report what you see and draw a general conclusion. For example, a solution that turns aqueous potassium iodide from colourless to brown contains an oxidising agent.
Qualitative analysis means finding out which substances a sample contains, not how much. In 1841 the German chemist Carl Remigius Fresenius published a guide to it. It ran to many editions and became a standard work for chemists.
Check your understanding
Which of these is an observation rather than an inference?
Show the answer
A white precipitate forms when silver nitrate is added.
An observation is what you see. "Chloride is present" is an inference you draw from that observation, after a correct test with nitric acid and silver nitrate.
Check your understanding
Aqueous sodium hydroxide is added to iron(II) sulfate solution until in excess, and the tube is left to stand. Which is the best recorded observation?
Show the answer
Green precipitate, insoluble in excess, turning red-brown on standing
It names the precipitate and its colour, what happens in excess and the change on standing, in the words mark schemes use.
Watch out for this
A student says: "Light blue precipitate with aqueous ammonia, soluble in excess giving a dark blue solution; white precipitate with nitric acid and silver nitrate. So the compound is copper chloride." What is wrong with this?
Show the answer
The name must show the charge on the copper ion, because copper forms more than one ion. The tests show Cu2+ and Cl- ions, so the compound is copper(II) chloride, CuCl2. Examiners report answers that lost the mark by writing "copper chloride" or "iron sulfate". A significant number named only the metal ion when the question asked for the compound.
Exam-style question
A white solid P is tested as follows.
1. P + dilute hydrochloric acid → effervescence; gas Q gives a white precipitate with limewater. A colourless solution R forms.
2. R + aqueous sodium hydroxide, a little at a time → white precipitate S, which dissolves in excess to give a colourless solution.
3. R + aqueous ammonia, a little at a time → white precipitate, which dissolves in excess to give a colourless solution.
4. R + dilute nitric acid, then aqueous silver nitrate → white precipitate T.
(a) Identify P, Q, S and T. [4]
(b) Write the ionic equation, with state symbols, for the formation of S. [1]
(c) A student says test 4 shows that P contains chloride ions. Explain why this is wrong. [1] [6]
Saved on this browser only. Anyone using this browser can see it.