What this lesson teaches
I can judge which causes mattered most in conflicts such as Kashmir, the Arab-Israeli wars, Congo and Bosnia.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes of conflicts
I can judge how local states, the superpowers and the UN shaped how conflicts developed over time.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the roles of different actors in the development of conflicts over time
Make a guess
India and Pakistan fought three wars between 1947 and 1971. Do you think religion explains them all?
- Yes, each war was Hindus against Muslims.
- No, the superpowers caused each war and the states followed.
- No, religion, territory, security and decolonisation worked together.
Show the answer
No, religion, territory, security and decolonisation worked together.
Kashmir mattered to both national identities, and neither would give ground on sovereignty. The 1971 war began inside Pakistan.
Kashmir combined all the causes: religion and nationalism, territory and security, and water. The combatant states drove the conflict, while outsiders shaped its course.
The causes worked together. Religion and rival nationalisms explain why Kashmir mattered so much to each state's sense of itself. Territorial sovereignty is the right to rule a piece of land. It and security explain why neither state would give way.
Decolonisation set the stage. The rushed partition left borders, princely states and refugees unsettled.
Economic interests were real but less important. Water mattered, but a treaty settled it in 1960 while the conflict went on.
The causes changed over time. In 1947 and 1965 the focus was Kashmir. In 1971 the trigger was Bengali nationalism and a crackdown inside Pakistan.
The combatant states, the two that fought, were the main actors. Their leaders chose to fight in 1947, 1965 and 1971. The superpowers gave arms and diplomatic cover, and they pressed for ceasefires. The UN could stop the fighting only when both sides were ready.
- Causes
- Religion, nationalism, territory, security, water.
- Main actors
- The combatant states.
- Outsiders
- Superpowers armed, shielded and mediated; the UN arranged ceasefires.
Worked example: A US promise to India, 24 February 1954
When the USA agreed to arm Pakistan, President Eisenhower wrote to India's Prime Minister, Nehru. He promised to act if US aid to "any country, including Pakistan, is misused and directed against another in aggression".
- Superpower role: US arms made Pakistan's army stronger, and the alliance gave it a powerful friend.
- Combatant choice: the promise did not hold Pakistan's leaders back. In August 1965 they sent armed men into Indian Kashmir.
- Response: when war came, the USA and Britain cut off arms to both sides, not just Pakistan. This hurt Pakistan more, as its forces were weaker.
- Judgement: the superpower supplied means and made promises, but the combatant chose to fight. Outsiders shaped how wars went more than why they began.
Watch out for this
Religion explains every war between India and Pakistan.
Religion shaped Partition and Kashmir, but the 1971 war was fought over Bengali nationalism within a Muslim state. Security and territory matter too.
Check your understanding
What does the 1971 war show about religion as a cause?
- Shared Islam did not keep Pakistan together; Bengali nationalism mattered more.
- Religion played no part in any of the wars.
- It was a religious war between Hindu India and Muslim Pakistan.
Show the answer
Shared Islam did not keep Pakistan together; Bengali nationalism mattered more.
Right. It limits religion as an explanation.
Check your understanding
In 1954 Eisenhower promised India he would act if US aid to Pakistan were used in aggression. In 1965 the USA cut off arms to both sides. What does this suggest about the superpowers' role?
- They could arm and restrain, but the combatants chose when to fight.
- The USA ordered Pakistan to start the 1965 war.
- The USA sided firmly with India against Pakistan in 1965.
Show the answer
They could arm and restrain, but the combatants chose when to fight.
Right. The decision to fight in 1965 was made in Pakistan, not Washington.