What this lesson teaches
I can judge how local states, the superpowers and the UN shaped how conflicts developed over time.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the roles of different actors in the development of conflicts over time
I can judge how well diplomacy, peacekeeping and peace talks managed conflicts.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the effectiveness of conflict management
Make a guess
In 1965 India and Pakistan fought a short war. What do you think the 1966 Tashkent Declaration did?
- Restored the old lines without settling Kashmir.
- Gave Kashmir to Pakistan in return for peace.
- Settled the Kashmir dispute with a new border.
Show the answer
Restored the old lines without settling Kashmir.
Soviet mediation ended the war, and both sides withdrew to their earlier positions. The core dispute remained.
Pakistan's bid to spark a revolt in Kashmir led to a war neither side won. Outsiders forced a ceasefire; Soviet talks restored the lines.
By the 1960s the superpowers were involved. Pakistan joined Western alliances in 1954 and 1955 and received American arms. The USSR backed India. It vetoed Security Council resolutions on Kashmir that India opposed, in 1957 and 1962.
In 1962 China defeated India in a short border war, and India looked weak. Pakistan's leaders were President Ayub Khan and Foreign Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. They believed they had a brief chance to act before India rearmed.
In August 1965 Pakistan sent armed men across the ceasefire line into Indian Kashmir. It hoped to spark a local revolt. The revolt did not happen. On 6 September India crossed the international border towards Lahore, and a wider war followed.
Neither side could win quickly. The UN Security Council demanded a ceasefire, which took effect on 23 September 1965.
The Soviet premier, Alexei Kosygin, invited both leaders to Tashkent in the USSR. There, in January 1966, they agreed to pull back to their pre-war positions. The Kashmir question itself was left open.
- Sino-Indian War
- 1962: India defeated by China.
- 1965 ceasefire
- 23 September 1965.
- Tashkent Declaration
- January 1966: back to pre-war positions.
Worked example: The Tashkent Declaration, 10 January 1966
Ayub Khan and India's Prime Minister, Lal Bahadur Shastri, met at Tashkent from 4 to 10 January 1966. Kosygin played an active part in the talks.
- Terms: all armed personnel were to go back to "the positions they held prior to" 5 August 1965, by 25 February 1966.
- Result: the UN reported the pull-back complete on 25 February, on schedule.
- Gap: on Kashmir, the text said only that each side set out "its respective position".
- Judgement: Soviet diplomacy ended the war cleanly. It left the cause of the war untouched.
Watch out for this
The Tashkent Declaration settled the Kashmir dispute.
It restored the pre-war positions and ended the fighting, but it did not settle who should control Kashmir.
Check your understanding
Why did Pakistan launch the operation in August 1965?
- India had invaded East Pakistan, and Pakistan wanted to draw Indian troops away.
- It hoped to spark a revolt in Kashmir while India was weak after 1962.
- The UN had ordered a vote that Pakistan wanted to force.
Show the answer
It hoped to spark a revolt in Kashmir while India was weak after 1962.
Right. The revolt did not happen.
Check your understanding
Tashkent sent both armies back to the positions they held before 5 August 1965. What did this choice of date mean?
- Neither side kept any land it had taken in the war.
- Pakistan kept the land its fighters had taken in Kashmir.
- India kept the land it had taken near Lahore.
Show the answer
Neither side kept any land it had taken in the war.
Right. The date marked the start of the 1965 fighting, so all gains were undone.