How effective was conflict management?

H2 History - syllabus 9174, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can judge how well diplomacy, peacekeeping and peace talks managed conflicts.

    Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the effectiveness of conflict management

Make a guess

UN diplomacy brought ceasefires in 1949 and 1965, and India and Pakistan signed the Simla Agreement after the 1971 war. Do you think conflict management solved the dispute?

  1. No, it limited the fighting but never solved the core disputes.
  2. Yes, the UN plebiscite settled Kashmir's future.
  3. No, because UN troops fought both armies and were driven out.
Show the answer

No, it limited the fighting but never solved the core disputes.

Ceasefires and observers limited the fighting, and the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty worked, but Kashmir stayed unresolved.

Ceasefires and observers limited the fighting, but no agreement solved the core dispute over Kashmir. The Indus Waters Treaty was the clearest success.

UN diplomacy brought ceasefires in 1949 and 1965. Both came only once the fighting had stalled. In 1971 Soviet vetoes blocked the Security Council. That war ended when Pakistan's forces in the east gave up and India declared a ceasefire. The vote the UN called for in 1948 was never held.

UN peacekeeping meant watching, not fighting. UNMOGIP, a group of unarmed military observers, has watched the Kashmir ceasefire line since 1949. A second mission, UNIPOM, watched the 1965 ceasefire along the rest of the border. Observers reported breaches but could not stop wars.

Great-power talks worked when the two sides were ready. Soviet talks at Tashkent in 1966 restored the pre-war lines. But the deal was unpopular in both countries and left Kashmir open.

The Simla Agreement of 2 July 1972 was made by the two states alone. The line where fighting stopped on 17 December 1971 became the Line of Control. Both sides promised to settle their differences peacefully, by bilateral talks or other agreed means. The deal reflected India's victory, and the line lasted. But Kashmir stayed disputed.

The World Bank brokered the Indus Waters Treaty of 1960 after nine years of talks. It gave the three eastern rivers to India and the three western rivers mainly to Pakistan. It survived the wars of 1965 and 1971. Shared needs such as water could be managed even when rival claims to land could not.

UNMOGIP
Observers since 1949.
UNIPOM
Watched the 1965 ceasefire, 1965-1966.
Indus Waters Treaty
1960, World Bank: survived the wars of 1965 and 1971.

Worked example: UN observers in the 1965 war

On 3 September 1965 the UN Secretary-General, U Thant, told the Security Council that the 1949 ceasefire agreement had collapsed. UN observers had watched that line for 16 years.

  1. Diplomacy: the Council called for a ceasefire on 4 September. The war still spread for more than two weeks.
  2. Peacekeeping: UNMOGIP grew to 102 observers. The new UNIPOM sent 90 more to the border outside Kashmir.
  3. Limits: UNIPOM's observers had "no authority or power to order a cessation of firing". They could report breaches and try to persuade local commanders.
  4. Judgement: the UN could ask, watch and report. Fighting stopped only when both sides were ready and outsiders pressed them.

Watch out for this

Conflict management failed completely because wars kept happening.

Ceasefires held after each war, and observers watched the line. Management limited the damage even though it did not resolve Kashmir.

Check your understanding

Why did the Indus Waters Treaty last when other agreements did not?

  1. It was enforced by UN troops on the rivers.
  2. It dealt with a shared resource, with clear rules and World Bank support.
  3. It gave Kashmir to India in return for Pakistan's water rights.
Show the answer

It dealt with a shared resource, with clear rules and World Bank support.

Right. It avoided the political question of sovereignty.

Check your understanding

UN observers had watched Kashmir's ceasefire line since 1949, yet war came in 1965. What does this show about peacekeeping by observers?

  1. It worked, because the observers ended the war within days.
  2. It could watch and report, but not stop a planned war.
  3. It failed because the observers sided with Pakistan.
Show the answer

It could watch and report, but not stop a planned war.

Right. Observers had no power to order a ceasefire, let alone enforce one.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready