What this lesson teaches
I can judge which causes mattered most in conflicts such as Kashmir, the Arab-Israeli wars, Congo and Bosnia.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes of conflicts
Make a guess
In October 1947 tribal fighters from Pakistan invaded Kashmir, whose Hindu ruler had hoped to stay independent. What do you think the ruler did?
- Joined Pakistan, since most of Kashmir's people were Muslim.
- Declared independence and won UN protection.
- Asked India for help and signed accession to India.
Show the answer
Asked India for help and signed accession to India.
Indian troops were flown in, and war with Pakistan followed. The UN arranged a ceasefire but never the promised vote.
Kashmir joined India after a Pakistani-backed invasion, which started the first war. The UN arranged a ceasefire but not the promised vote.
Kashmir was a princely state. Most of its people were Muslim, but its ruler, Maharaja Hari Singh, was Hindu. He hoped to stay independent.
In October 1947 tribal fighters from Pakistan invaded. The Maharaja asked India for help. He signed an Instrument of Accession, a legal paper joining his state to India. Indian troops were flown in, and war with Pakistan followed.
Each side had a claim. India relied on the legal accession. Pakistan said a Muslim-majority state on its border should be part of Pakistan. Kashmir also mattered for security. Rivers that watered Pakistan's farms flowed through it.
India took the dispute to the UN Security Council in January 1948. In April the Council asked Pakistan to get the tribal fighters out. India was then to cut its forces. Last, a plebiscite would be held. A plebiscite is a vote by the people on one question.
A ceasefire began on 1 January 1949, and UN military observers came to watch it. The Karachi Agreement of July 1949 fixed the ceasefire line. Neither side withdrew as asked, and the plebiscite was never held.
- Accession
- October 1947: the Maharaja joins India.
- Resolution 47
- April 1948: a plebiscite called for.
- Ceasefire
- 1 January 1949; UNMOGIP observers.
Worked example: Resolution 47, 21 April 1948
The Security Council noted "with satisfaction" that India and Pakistan both wanted Kashmir's future settled by "a free and impartial plebiscite". It then set out the steps to get there.
- First: Pakistan was to secure "the withdrawal" of the "tribesmen and Pakistani nationals" who had come to fight.
- Next: India was to cut its forces "progressively to the minimum strength" needed to keep order.
- Then: a plebiscite administrator named by the UN would run the vote.
- Judgement: the order of steps was the problem. Pakistan had to move first, while Indian troops stayed. Neither side trusted the other, so the vote never came.
Watch out for this
The UN failed in Kashmir because it did nothing.
The UN arranged a ceasefire and sent observers who stayed. It failed to secure the plebiscite because neither India nor Pakistan would withdraw as required.
Check your understanding
What did the UN Security Council call for in April 1948?
- A plebiscite after Pakistani withdrawal and a cut in Indian forces
- Kashmir to join Pakistan because most people were Muslim
- A UN army to fight in Kashmir until the war ended
Show the answer
A plebiscite after Pakistani withdrawal and a cut in Indian forces
Right. The vote never took place.
Check your understanding
Resolution 47 noted that India and Pakistan both wanted a plebiscite. Why was no vote ever held?
- The UN decided Kashmir's people were too divided to vote.
- Kashmir's ruler had already joined Pakistan in 1947.
- Neither side would make the troop moves that had to come first.
Show the answer
Neither side would make the troop moves that had to come first.
Right. The vote depended on withdrawals that never happened.