What this lesson teaches
I can judge how well diplomacy, peacekeeping and peace talks managed conflicts.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the effectiveness of conflict management
I can judge which causes mattered most in conflicts such as Kashmir, the Arab-Israeli wars, Congo and Bosnia.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes of conflicts
Make a guess
UN peacekeepers watched Arab-Israeli borders from 1948, yet wars came in 1967 and 1973. Do you think peacekeeping failed?
- No, it had solved the whole conflict by 1979.
- Not entirely: it kept long periods of calm.
- Yes, because wars still broke out in 1967 and 1973.
Show the answer
Not entirely: it kept long periods of calm.
UNEF kept Sinai calm from 1957 to 1967, and observers still watch some lines. Rival claims to the land remained.
Rival claims to the same land drove the conflict; security fears set off each war. Management contained wars but made only a partial peace.
The core cause was nationalism over territory: two peoples claiming the same land. Decolonisation turned this into war when Britain left in 1948.
Security fears explain the timing of wars. Each side saw the other's moves as threats, as in May 1967. Economic interests, such as the Suez Canal and later oil, widened the conflict.
UN peacekeeping had real successes. UNTSO observers stayed from 1948. UNEF kept Sinai quiet from 1957 to 1967. UNDOF has kept the Golan front quiet since 1974. But peacekeepers needed consent, as UNEF's exit in 1967 showed.
Diplomacy achieved most when the combatants wanted it. The 1949 armistices and Kissinger's disengagement deals of 1974-1975 stopped the fighting. Camp David made a lasting peace between Egypt and Israel.
Overall, management turned a series of wars into a partial peace by 1979. It did not resolve the Palestinian question.
- Core cause
- Two national movements claiming the same land.
- Peacekeeping
- UNTSO 1948, UNEF 1956-1967, UNEF II 1973-1979, UNDOF from 1974.
- Partial peace
- Egypt-Israel treaty 1979; the Palestinian question remains.
Worked example: UNEF leaves Sinai, 16-18 May 1967
On the evening of 16 May 1967 Egypt's army chief asked UNEF to pull back from its posts on the border. Egyptian troops then moved onto UNEF's line.
- Consent: U Thant said the force was on Egyptian soil only with Egypt's consent and could not stay without it.
- Buffer: he asked Israel to host UNEF on its side of the line. Israel refused.
- Council: the USA and the USSR were on opposite sides, so U Thant judged the Security Council could not act. UNEF began leaving on 19 May.
- Judgement: UNEF kept Sinai quiet for over ten years, but only while both sides consented. It could not hold a line that a state wanted open.
Watch out for this
Peacekeeping failed because wars happened in 1967 and 1973.
Peacekeeping kept fronts quiet for long periods. It could not stop states that chose war, because it depended on their consent.
Check your understanding
What does the end of UNEF in 1967 show?
- The USA closed UNEF to save money.
- The UN force was beaten in battle by Egypt's army.
- UN peacekeepers depended on the host state's consent.
Show the answer
UN peacekeepers depended on the host state's consent.
Right. Egypt asked them to leave.
Check your understanding
Why did U Thant not take UNEF's exit to the Security Council in May 1967?
- The Council had already voted to end UNEF in 1966.
- Israel had asked the Council to remove UNEF from Sinai.
- The USA and USSR disagreed, so the Council could not act.
Show the answer
The USA and USSR disagreed, so the Council could not act.
Right. Peacekeeping depended on superpower agreement as well as the host's consent.