What this lesson teaches
I can judge how well diplomacy, peacekeeping and peace talks managed conflicts.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the effectiveness of conflict management
Make a guess
In 1979 Egypt and Israel signed a peace treaty after US talks at Camp David. Do you think it ended the Arab-Israeli conflict?
- No, because Israel refused to return any land to Egypt.
- Yes, the other Arab states made peace with Israel too.
- No, it ended the conflict with Egypt alone.
Show the answer
No, it ended the conflict with Egypt alone.
Egypt recognised Israel and got Sinai back. The plan for Palestinian self-rule was never carried out.
Sadat's bold moves and US mediation made the first peace between Israel and an Arab state. It left the Palestinian question open.
In November 1977 Sadat flew to Jerusalem and spoke to Israel's parliament, the Knesset. No Arab leader had made a public visit to Israel before.
Talks then stalled. US President Jimmy Carter invited Sadat and Israel's Prime Minister, Menachem Begin, to Camp David in September 1978. After 13 days they agreed two frameworks. One was for an Egypt-Israel treaty. The other was for Palestinian self-rule.
The Egypt-Israel Peace Treaty was signed on 26 March 1979. Egypt recognised Israel. Israel agreed to return all of Sinai, which it completed in 1982. The USA gave both countries large amounts of aid.
The peace held because both leaders gained. Sadat won back Sinai and US support for Egypt's economy. Begin removed the strongest Arab army from the conflict.
The Palestinian framework failed. Other Arab states rejected the deal, and the Arab League suspended Egypt. Sadat was assassinated in 1981. The conflict over the West Bank and Gaza went on.
- Sadat in Jerusalem
- November 1977.
- Camp David Accords
- September 1978.
- Peace treaty
- March 1979; Sinai returned by 1982.
Worked example: The Camp David Accords, 17 September 1978
Begin and Sadat signed two frameworks, with Carter as witness. The first said the basis for peace was Resolution 242 "in all its parts".
- Egypt and Israel: they aimed to sign a peace treaty "within three months". They missed it; the treaty came in March 1979. Israeli forces would then leave Sinai in stages.
- Palestinians: the West Bank and Gaza were to get "full autonomy" under an elected "self-governing authority", for up to five years.
- Gaps: the frameworks set no status for Jerusalem. Later talks on self-rule failed, as Palestinian representatives refused to take part.
- Judgement: Camp David settled what Egypt and Israel could trade directly. It left the Palestinian question for later.
Watch out for this
Camp David ended the Arab-Israeli conflict.
It ended the conflict between Egypt and Israel. Syria, Jordan and the Palestinians were not part of the peace, and the Palestinian question remained.
Check your understanding
Why did the Arab League suspend Egypt in 1979?
- Egypt made a separate peace with Israel.
- Egypt had left the UN and the Non-Aligned Movement.
- Egypt had attacked Saudi Arabia in a border war.
Show the answer
Egypt made a separate peace with Israel.
Right. Other Arab states saw it as betrayal.
Check your understanding
Camp David promised the West Bank and Gaza "full autonomy" within five years. Why did the Egypt-Israel peace last when this part did not?
- Egypt and Israel could trade Sinai directly; Palestinians were not party to it.
- The UN took charge of the West Bank and Gaza in 1979.
- Israel handed the West Bank to Jordan in 1979.
Show the answer
Egypt and Israel could trade Sinai directly; Palestinians were not party to it.
Right. The treaty dealt with what the two signers controlled.