What this lesson teaches
I can judge which causes mattered most in conflicts such as Kashmir, the Arab-Israeli wars, Congo and Bosnia.
Syllabus 9174, Paper 1, Theme III, Learning Outcomes. evaluate the causes of conflicts
Make a guess
In November 1947 the UN voted to divide Palestine into a Jewish state and an Arab state. What do you think happened when Britain left in 1948?
- Britain stayed on to enforce the plan by force.
- War broke out, Israel was founded, and many Palestinians became refugees.
- Both sides accepted the plan and set up two peaceful states.
Show the answer
War broke out, Israel was founded, and many Palestinians became refugees.
Two national movements claimed the same land. Arab states attacked the new Israel, and the war left a lasting refugee crisis.
Two national movements claimed the same land. Britain's exit in 1948 led to war, the state of Israel and a Palestinian refugee crisis.
Britain ruled Palestine after the First World War, under a League of Nations mandate. A mandate was land that one power ran for the League. Jewish immigration grew. It was driven by Zionism, the movement for a Jewish national home, and by persecution in Europe. Palestinian Arabs opposed it and wanted an independent Arab state.
After the Holocaust, pressure for a Jewish state grew. Britain was worn down by violence from both sides. In 1947 it handed the problem to the UN.
In November 1947 the UN General Assembly voted to divide Palestine into a Jewish state and an Arab state. Jerusalem was to be under international control. Jewish leaders accepted the plan. Arab leaders rejected it.
Israel declared independence on 14 May 1948, as the British left. Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Iraq and Lebanon attacked. Israel won and ended up with more land than the plan had given it.
About 700,000 Palestinians fled or were driven from their homes. The UN mediator Ralph Bunche negotiated armistice agreements in 1949. But no Arab state recognised Israel.
- Resolution 181
- November 1947: partition plan.
- Israel
- Independence declared 14 May 1948.
- Refugees
- About 700,000 Palestinians.
Worked example: The partition vote, 29 November 1947
The UN General Assembly passed Resolution 181 by 33 votes to 13, with 10 abstentions. It said Britain's mandate would end "not later than 1 August 1948".
- Territory: it set up an Arab state, a Jewish state and a "Special International Regime for the City of Jerusalem".
- Nationalism: Jewish leaders accepted it. Arab leaders rejected the division of land they saw as theirs.
- Decolonisation: Britain was leaving, and no UN army stood behind the plan. Civil war broke out in Palestine soon after the vote.
- Judgement: the plan drew lines on paper. The war of 1948 decided where the real lines fell.
Watch out for this
The Arab-Israeli conflict was an ancient religious war.
It was mainly a modern conflict between two national movements over territory, made worse by the way British rule ended. Religion raised the stakes, especially over Jerusalem.
Check your understanding
What did the UN partition plan of November 1947 propose?
- A Jewish state, an Arab state and international control of Jerusalem
- A single Arab state in which Jewish areas governed themselves
- Continued British rule under a UN trusteeship until both sides agreed
Show the answer
A Jewish state, an Arab state and international control of Jerusalem
Right. Arab leaders rejected it.
Check your understanding
Resolution 181 passed by 33 votes to 13 in November 1947, but no UN army stood behind it. Why did this matter when Britain left?
- The Arab states accepted the plan once Britain left.
- The fighting, not the plan, would decide the borders.
- Britain stayed on to enforce the plan until 1949.
Show the answer
The fighting, not the plan, would decide the borders.
Right. Israel ended the 1948 war holding more land than the plan gave it.